Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Mental BM

 Michael Jordan said you miss 100% of the shots you don't take. Michael Jordan would never have said it if he didn't have a sneaker deal. 

It's not necessarily about shots you mean to finally take, it's about being true to oneself, being 'real,' taking the preparatory steps for the life you want by coming forward with what you really think or feel so that the next time, you will throw yourself in rather than wait god knows how long. 

Ever since the diagnosis: I increasingly don't think about work. As concerned as I am by it, I increasingly don't think about the stuff I leave behind. The ambition is very much still there, but what I really think about is love, how little I've had of it over the course of my years and the accompanying loneliness of the long distance life. It's a lonely thing, not to share life with anyone: even if the partners change from time to time. Doubtless, most relationships aren't that great either, but we're all hardwired to need it, even when we fail.

And yet, at 44, I have, to this day, never had a relationship which I did not come to regret. I'm not even sure I've ever had a confession of a crush I hadn't come to regret. If I could do it all again, I'd take a vow of chastity. Love in my life has never felt equal to loss.  I could be gay or queer and the end result would be exactly the same: there has never been a love in my life that was equal to the devastation I felt at its end. Never even so much as a sexual encounter felt like it resulted in something equally good as the end result was bad--except for the woman who kissed me when I made the exact same confession when I was twenty-four: it was my last night living in Israel and the consequences were easier to deal with.

It's not simply an attitude problem: it's literally a problem of brain chemistry. No amount of love can be equal to the loss: the brain and the nervous system simply absorbs the blow at a level others would probably find horrific, and easily more intense than anything which comes before: including love, including sex, including the simple memories of enjoyment. Perhaps that is just my lot in life, and a terrible lot it frankly is. To suffer eternal loneliness simply because of your own capacity for suffering: there are far worse ways to go through life, but is there any erotic punishment more Dante-esque?  

I've thrown my battered heart to two old female friends in the last month. TWO. What level of dementia does that take? What level of recklessness? I even used the same line of wanting to be in your arms to both of them. Did I love them both? Probably, at least at the moment. But I learned early on to never trust my own emotions, especially at the moment you feel them. I don't know what I feel because I'm not convinced it's me who feels them. Other people can live according to their hearts, but not when your heart does not feel like your own. And yet the paradox is, the tighter the grip of control on the heart, the more the heart fights and takes over the brain in what feels like an invasion. What hope is there for self-control when you're so clearly out of control? It often feels as though the more you try to control yourself, the more you go insane. 

Do I even feel the same way a week later? I have no idea, such is the life of mania where your heart doesn't belong to yourself but to a collection of trillions of overactive neurons. And yet... fuck it, I'm sick of carrying these emotional burdens alone. I'm sick of using a brain that was never particularly reliable to cover for a heart that is overly quick to every emotion and so overactive it may give out well before the party's over. I'm sick of people whom I tell exactly what it's like to be in this state act like they're dealing with a normal person. I try to cue them in for once to what it's like to have a physiognomy that's gone haywire for thirty-five years. They don't understand, maybe they don't want to understand: but what can you do? You keep trying, what other choice is there? 

So to the rest of the women reading this: watch out, you're clearly next. 

I've spent fifteen years on this blog writing myself out: whatever I think or feel, hoping that by touching on the personal or particular, I can bring out universal themes. At this point I'd imagine I've unpublished a full quarter of my best essays. I just know too much about what it does to my prospects: romantic and professional. Hell, I knew at the time, but the urgency of the feeling was too great to keep it to myself. I needed to write it, and I needed the possibility that other people see it, because otherwise there is no hope of change: just a continual isolation in a mind that was never particularly good at reminding itself that all is not as bad as it seems. These essays are my daily bread. When I write fiction, the mania rises to its height and I sometimes feel inspired by God. When I write essays, I feel like I've taken a shit. 

And yet, and yet...

It's taken me thirty years, but I've mastered the first impression. I've often I've gone on extremely successful dates, gotten a small snog in, then the girl begs off for the second date: I know what happens every time. They find this thing, and it's over before it begins. 

There is no reason for a normal person to write essays like this. There is no reason for a normal person to say what he's thinking out loud. It is only people of overwhelming lack of control, overwhelming emotions, overwhelming doubts and terrors. It is not actual isolation: it's certainly not the isolation meaning lack of friendships, though I would be happier if I tried a lot harder socially. 

Once upon a time, in my 20s. I had a hundred close friends. Probably a literal hundred. I would basically perform an oral version of this blog in front of them, and they would somehow accept it in the way young'uns in their twenties would accept over-intimacy: particularly young drunks. And yet I also seemed to be fighting with half of them at any given time: and half of my frustrations conveyed were of the friends who'd hurt me 'this week' and all these other friends reassuring me that it wasn't as bad as it seemed: a perpetual crisis mode that originated long before those years. With a mind that yo-yo'd like that, there was no romantic chance: how can you put yourself out there for a romantic chance when your mind yo-yo's in that way? Who would even accept you for it? 

Over the years I've speculated I have Borderline Personality Disorder, particularly lately: a string of therapists have assured me I don't. They say that some people just have enormous emotions. That's apparently what I have: Philip Roth said that he writes his emotions so he may not die from them. That is, to a letter, exactly how I feel about writing. If I didn't have the space to write things down, if I didn't have the hope that people would understand, I'd be long dead. 

It may be pathetic, but this is my long term relationship. The only one that ever gave me any reward and which I've never regretted getting into. words, the writing, the mental bowel movement. It's a relationship with a toilet, but at least the commode flushes. 

Will it be three days before this essay gets unpublished too?


Monday, November 16, 2026

Dear Dad from Berlin

 Dear Dad,

It has been an absolutely insane week and a half. Manic highs and unbearable lows. Drunken mistakes and sober clarity. It's the kind of week you would never permit yourself: perhaps with good reason, but it is, nevertheless, one of the most memorable weeks I've had in a long, long time. 

Ever since forty, my life was in deep freeze. Then I got the diagnosis, and I certainly felt like the diagnosis was true, and I had to start living again. Well, if this is living, life might be slightly overrated, but only slightly. 

Will it be over soon? I have no idea, but I'm going to live like it both is and isn't. No regrets, no caution, no morbidity. Live like I'm still 25 with it all ahead of me, this time not just liver damage again but with exercise: not for the agony of it but the sheer joy of feeling like I can beat the crap out of people in bars (even if I'd run away screaming from a fight). 

With the setting constantly changing, it's surprisingly hard to write fiction. No matter where you are, you depend on the energy you feel. I sort of feel too comfortable in Vienna, it so hums along with my way of life that I think to myself 'this is a little too wonderful.' Meanwhile, Berlin is exactly wrong. Too uptight and too much fun, too much establishment and too much rebellion, art everywhere that's trendy in that New York way, only without the patina of cool. Everything is modern here: at first I found it charming. Perhaps I'm in the wrong part of Berlin but now I find it incredibly ugly, unfriendly, impossible to relax without committing so hard to a way of life that you can only be embraced by your own scenesters. One friend finds Vienna boring: I suppose I'm boring then, but I like the mellowness. I like the predictability. I like the friendliness that is so obviously insincere. It is an extremely uncool but ironic, bittersweet way of life that jives with everything I know life to be. Berlin is like a Faustian city that tries to escape what life really is. Vienna just flows with the Danube. 

This has been a week full of heartbreak and joy: fifteen year questons were answered and riddles solved, reunions and isolations, and music, music, music. Music like you could never experience in Baltimore. Was it better than in Baltimore? Some of it, not most, but my god, the options, the regularity, the constant presence of it. 

There's been next to no research done this week. I had neither the mood nor the energy nor the patience for all those Nazi sites I wanted to visit. I'll have to come back, on my undistracted time no doubt, and I go back to Vienna still imagining the Berlin I have to write about. 

They told me not to go. You would have told me never to go. I went to Berlin, full of dreams I knew were impossible and extraordinarily unwise. You spent your life trying not to be foolish. I will not make your mistake anymore. 

But to be foolish, you have to keep your mind clear. You have to keep your eyes wide about the dangers, or else you will be forever the fool. People can be incredibly complicated: incredibly generous yet self-absorbed, incredibly smart yet foolish, incredibly realistic yet self-deluded, humble yet full of hubris, wise yet self-destructive, mature yet childish, selfless yet desperately craving admiration, altruistic yet narcissistic yet considerate yet fascinating. In other words, not ideal people, but humans, like you,... ok, not you, you were another level of outsize from anybody else, and like you, I love them for their weaknesses as well as their strengths. 

Life is a very weird place, I hope I stay in it for a long time and experience the positive parts of it as well as the negative. I don't know how long I have, but I don't feel like I have another 50 years, let alone another 30. I'll keep trying to get my health in check (and probably failing), I'll keep trying not to die, but to not die is not worth not truly living. 

Love,

Evan 

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Haley Stevens: A Letter to American Jews

 

When I first heard what Haley did (again... Eagles will understand what I mean...), my first reaction was not about Haley, it was not about the country, it was not about the election, it was not even about the state of Jews or Muslims: my thought was very simple:
"For the rest of my mother's life I'm going to hear what a hero my friend Haley is."
The underlying message, as it is with all Jewish mothers, is 'why can't you be more like Haley?'
And it's always 'Haley.' Even when it's not Haley it's 'Haley.' For those who grew up among American Jews, it should be no secret why Haley Stevens found common cause with us. I grew up with three dozen Haley Stevenses, so did the rest of you, some of you WERE Haley Stevens and I worry still are. They go by all kinds of names: Tracy Flick, Leslie Knope, Paris Geller, Alex Dunphy, Annie Edison, Hillary Clinton, Carlton Banks, Alexander Portnoy, Max Fischer, Pete Buttigieg, Ben Shapiro, even Mark Zuckerberg.
I don't know what Haley's going to do next, but I do know, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that Haley will clean up on the extremely lucrative Jewish speakers circuit: synagogues, Hillel houses, charitable organizations, she will make hundreds of thousands on it, probably millions, be treated like a hero, and no matter what her motivation for her vote, she can invent a story of the greatest heroism and 90% of the Jews I know will eat up her every word. She will be speaking in my town of origin every year for the next twenty, and should I stay there, the awkward question every year will be 'Should we get lunch?' I'd imagine after what follows, the answer will only be 'yes' after the first ten years.
In Yiddish there is a word called 'Nakhes.' Nakhes is the warm, deep pride you have from another person's achievements: particularly the achievements of your kids. Many immigrants raise their children to be 'nakhes machines,' and the drive to churn out of achievement always lasts for some family members a hundred years or more after we get off the boat. The genetic vestige is always there: the world as we know it can disappear tomorrow, we need to achieve while we can, and maybe, just maybe, our achievements will buy us a very little bit of security when things get hairy. It never buys that security, but it gives some people piece of mind to think it does.
Haley seems to come from the opposite of that. For all I know she came from Old Money, but that desire to achieve never slaked, and like so many people I knew growing up in the extraordinarily strange environs of Pikesville, MD, I get the sense she learned values that are not as rock solid as we'd like to pretend they are. Like Haley, many of us were taught that achievement matters more than community, more than loyalty, more than friendship, occasionally even more than family. When it came time for my generation of Baltimore Jews to choose between achievement and loyalty, barely any of them even hesitated. Everybody I knew growing up migrated to DC, to New York, to much farther afield to be lawyers, doctors, policy analysts. Very few took the unglamorous work of high school teacher or nurse or HVAC technician. They left behind a city that could not need them more direly: their connections, their practicality, their will to achieve, their desire to fill whatever community they grace with 'nakhes.'
It's not like I'm immune to this. I'm a 44 year old underachiever, but my ambitions are still massive and megalomaniacal. Others want to be the most powerful lawyer or best doctor in their cities, but even in a midlife of mediocre health, I can't let go of the idea that I can be Judaism's Dostoevsky, Milton, Dante: maybe if I'm a giant of literature, my father will finally approve of me.
Such jobs were frankly a little looked down on: it was rarely ever said aloud, but we knew. Our teachers were generally not the smartest of us, at least in Jewish Day Schools they were generally the wives of doctors who needed something to do during the day and showed up to work in 500 dollar pantsuits, and then some of our parents wondered how we got so little education in the humanities and how our Jewish knowledge was so lacking. We had some great teachers, one or two I'm still friends with, but they were shining exceptions. Yet somehow, most of us went from that to jobs that were only three degrees removed from really impressive. It's as though everybody I knew growing up got magnificent educations while showing little evidence of it.
The reason for all this is that we were taught snobbery from a very early age, not least from those teachers, and the smart kids were told by their parents to feel destined for better things. It rubbed off on a lot of us. Jews are often thought of as supercilious, and there's a little bit of truth to it: no moreso than other ethnicities known for their bourgeois ethics, but we definitely have our snobbish side as a people: believing not only that we're smarter, but that our character is higher. It's an unfortunate belief: and even were it true, it's the sort of pride that sets us up for a terrible fall.
For many of us, this morning is manna for the starving. I don't want to pour cold water on everybody, but we're not out of the woods until Trump is gone. We think Trump is done: he's not. He becomes especially dangerous now: we don't know what he will do, but an evil man like that will fight only the harder when his pride is injured: January 6th proved it, and the probable hell which comes now is entirely fresh.
And in some ways, a probable nightmare is still only beginning. Not a nightmare for everybody, but a nightmare for 'us,' for Jews. A nightmare that in many ways, we brought upon ourselves.
It may have happened anyway: antisemitism is madness, but irrationality is only compounded by further irrationality. Nothing is more irrational than a persecuted minority that becomes conspicuously successful. To be Jewish is to keep your head down, achieve what you can, and settle for second best.
We may be about to have a Jewish President. Jon Ossoff is currently agreeable to every side of the Democratic party, and a capable politician enough to ingratiate himself to moderates, leftists and Republicans. He is not, however, capable enough to ingratiate himself to the forces of history. It is not a good idea to have a Jewish President in the world's most powerful country any more than it's a good idea to have a Jewish foreign policy czar like Henry Kissinger or a Jewish Prime Minister like Benjamin Disraeli. In the long run, it can only increase antisemitism, it can only increase conspiracy theories of Jewish power, the ramifications can be felt for 100 years.
Back in the 19th century, English Prime Ministers were supposed to be intellectuals, and Benjamin Disraeli wrote a novel, Conningsby, which contained a Jewish character who secretly controlled a network that moved the levers of the world. This was a good, benevolent character, and for a hundred years was taken as evidence of a Jewish world conspiracy.
For some reason, on the day of our election, we find out that the United States and Israel are ending their funding agreement.
Be realistic, what do people really think is going to happen from this?
Israel no longer needs the money. It has a GDP of 500 billion dollars a year, against the US's 4 billion dollar a year loan. Even ten years ago, the loan would have some effect. But Israel has developed economically at light speed: more startups per capita than any country on earth. The idea that the loan has much effect at this point is a bit laughable. What's the point of the loan?
The point is a declaration of mutual alliance. It's a blue ribbon certification: telling US investors that Israel is a rock solid certification, and in exchange, the US gets use of Mossad's intelligence, which according to one general is worth 'Five CIA's.
Israel no longer needs America's blue ribbon certification, but if the US and Israel move in separate directions while America moves left, divisions of the near-future will dwarf what Jews experience now.
The US loan guarantees is not what enables Israel's behavior but what prevents Israel from further misbehavior. An Israel without American restraints has no reason to not lay waste to the entire Middle East, thereby risking war on a scale few Jews have yet imagined.
Now let's say Ossoff is President when all this happens? Ossoff will be compelled to oppose Israel to the fullest extent of international relations, particularly because of his Jewish background. And no matter how much he does, he will still be seen as being in the pocket of Jewish interests.
What Haley did was a mixture of comedy, spite and somebody's sinister intentions, but the amount of conspiracy theories which instantly proliferated was uncanny. Barely within an hour, Haley was alleged to take instructions from the Democratic National Committee after the Democratic party had poured unprecedented resources into electing al-Sayed. Haley was equated not only with John Fetterman but with Tulsi Gabbard: an anti-queer elected and appointed official who crossed over to Trump after being considered far-left, and is basically proven to be an agent of both Russia and Syria.
People who believe these things are, quite literally, insane. Crazier even than Haley. They're capable of believing any conspiracy theory at all and it's only a matter of time before some RFK Jr. sways them (a figure against whom Haley led the charge by the way...).
Haley is as complicated a person as I've ever met. But what was clear to me from the moment we met was that she had no peace of mind.
I will never forget the moment I met her: we were freshmen, I was severely drunk yet I immediately realized this was no neurotypical student: her mind was chaos. She came right up to me and said 'Let's have a conversation, we've obviously been gearing to have one for a long time.' My first thought was 'oh my god I've got a shot here...' But I tried to have that conversation, and over the course of ten or twenty minutes, Haley must have changed the subject at least fifteen times. That was her way, it still seems to be her way. I'm still frankly amazed she had the focus for a political career.
The only explanation I had for it is that this chaos was a put on, that the real Haley was a singularly focused career animal and the constant mental darting was just a performance, a put-on to hide a lethally focused mind.
Yet here is evidence that it is no put-on at all. Haley really was chaos from the moment I met her until now. When she said "Israel appears to me in my dreams," I remember how seriously she seemed to take astrology in college, and I honestly wonder if that's the reason she supports Israel and there is no reason more substantial than that.
It's not that Haley is without substance, she's the opposite of that. Anyone who's talked philosophy and history with her knows that this is no 'woo-woo.' But in my experience she was always incapable of connecting the various thoughts in her head into something coherent, and thus was a bit open to the same bullshit as the conspiracy theorists who probably made her life a living hell for the past year. Even in her incoherence, she was utterly brilliant, the spontaneous combustion bringing her an eloquence and charisma that was mesmeric. There is literally no one like Haley Stevens in the entire world: the moment you meet her, you remember her forever.
But I've resolved that beneath all that is a person forced by someone to be the exact opposite sort of person: I don't know if it was her mother, some childhood friends, some teachers, or some deep inner compulsion to prove herself that she did not even understand herself. But I wonder, did she look at Jewish friends like the ones I grew up with, and felt the same mixture of jealousy, intimidation, awe and searing resentment I felt? As though she had to compete with them, rise higher than them, be 'better' than them.
In that sense, the only difference between her and me is that she succeeded. American Jews of my generation are populated by a hundred thousand Haley Stevenses, and it makes a certain sense that she found her motivation in these sort of circles of Jewish meritocrats.
And the values of the Jewish meritocracy screwed her just as it screwed so many people I know. She seems to be going down with our ship, and the fate of Haley Stevens is the fate we all may share fairly soon.
May she and we find better fortune.
Amen

Monday, November 2, 2026

More Thoughts on Haley


.
I just don't know what to do today. I thought I was exempt from thinking about my country by leaving, yet here I am, with it occupying as much thought as ever. I'm not tempted to go back, even with two bad ankles, but sadness is here too: so much that the sadness of America is half of why I don't want to go back for a while. .
Haley's decision is the kind of iconoclasm I should be celebrating: she took a stand against both Abdul el-Sayed and Tucker Carlson: she showed that hard right and hard left are the same thing: and she showed that when nobody else resists it, someone can resist it. There's a 1% chance she'll be vindicated as a hero who kept to principles when no one else did. And furthermore, if we wanted to minimize the damage done, the reaction today could not have been worse. By the fact that half the country ganged up on Haley to a level almost without precedent, however deserved, will prove to the center that we are as partisan as Republicans allege we are. In the last 24 hours, we probably delivered every undecided voter to Republicans.
But that sort of line in the sand was what James Comey thought, and now we have Donald Trump, and part of Joe Biden's calculation, I'm sure, was that by running again, he was saving us from Bernie Sanders.
Sometimes, there are no good choices: you just do what you can to not rock the boat, you put your head down, and hope like hell that entropy blows all the problems over.
Every moderate to liberal Democrat knows that the DSA is a different species entirely from anything in the Democratic party since perhaps Henry Wallace. Many Republicans stepped through the dimensional doorway since Joseph McCarthy: but the dimensional doorway is not between fascism and socialism: it's between conservatism and socialism. Virtually the entire world but our country agrees that American conservatism flirts with something authoritarian: and that's exactly what right-wingers in other countries seem to like about Republicans.
In a properly functioning democracy, what we call moderation is what should be called conservatism, progressivism is the left, and liberalism is the vital center of discourse. Democracy means the right to have any opinion at all, but the ideological conditions that let democracy flourish are small indeed. You either believe in a conglomeration of liberty and equality with neither subsuming the other, or you don't. You either believe that people's achievements are substantially helped by government services, public roads, regulated industry, public health initiatives, or you don't. If you don't, I'm sorry to say you support the tyranny of the powerful over the powerless no less than any socialist. You either support freedom of speech and press without retribution, you either support people's abilities to withstand massive public pressure to speak their minds or vote whatever they deem to be their conscience, you either believe in the love of family and the pride of self-creation, or you don't. If you don't, you support the tyranny of the winners over the losers no less than any conservative.
The vital center does not mean the middle position in any issue: it means embracing the root solution in any given issue, and that solution may be found all across the political spectrum, including on the right. If all your positions in life are by rote, determined by the group, determined by a sense that what you and friends believe is the inevitable side of good: how are you an individual? You may have enabled certain parts of your identity, but you've surrendered the personality that is uniquely yours. You have literally become your identity, and nothing more: and that goes for right as well as left.
This is the dimensional doorway through which America has now stepped: a doorway through which has stepped a hundred other democracies and republics before us. We are no longer who we are, we are what we believe. We have become our politics, nothing more. All those other things that used to define us: entertainment and art, math and science, sports, they now take back seats to whatever we believe politically.
No country can function like that, no country has ever functioned like that.
Haley supposedly acted in the interests of Jews like the righteous gentile. What did she really do? She brought still more attention on us that we don't need. The one thing hard right and hard left have in common is a searing hatred of Jewish interests. They may not see it as antisemitism, but everything that is in the interests of Jews: Jewish survival, Jewish security, Jewish prosperity and equality and freedom, they revile.
So what did Haley do? She used the Jewish state to help determine an election still more than it already is. Nothing good can come from that: it only increases the attention, pressure and hatred directed towards us.
Haley is neither a hero or a villain: she is human. She always was, she clearly will always be. From some mix of bruised ego from distant people who wish her ill, and coercive pressure from close people who don't wish her well, she made a terrible choice that a lot of misguided Jews are going to laud as an heroically righteous one. Today, my old friend is the most famous person in America, with all the acclaim and vitriol that goes along with that. Many of the conspiracy theories said about Haley have been abhorrent: but I don't know what she expected, and more importantly, what her fiance expected. This is a person who is supposed to protect his spouse, and by all accounts, he pointed her in the direction of the lions.
Haley's actions are ultimately not his responsibility: they're Haley's. But Haley is now a minor chapter in American history, potentially to be mentioned in some high school textbooks, and probably in Jewish history too. She will not be remembered as a straightforward hero. She will be remembered as the deeply conflicted person she is: torn as she always was between immense altruism and warmth, and immense ego and chaos.
Haley, thank you for acting in what you think are the interests of my people: but the history of the Jews is the history of unintended consequences. So many heroes in Jewish history caused more suffering than they liberated us from, and we deal with the consequences of these false heroes in every era.
Whether or not Jews commemorate you as a hero, whether or not your endorsement is ultimately vindicated in the eyes of history, The fact still remains: you have stepped onto the faultlines of history, and your stand may have caused a populace that will blame Jews particularly for whatever chaos follows.
I hope you and your name stay unbesmirched in what follows, but if this is what you strove so hard to achieve, if this is why you left us for Oxford, I still don't know why you did all that. This is not the first time your chaos publicly burned a massive bridge, but now the bridge is on a literal million times the scale, and just like last time, I hope you're considering what you did all that for.

Sunday, November 1, 2026

My Dear Haley


For the last week and a half, I have not been American.
Without really thinking it through, I bought a ticket to leave America on October 20th, the birthday of my Bubbie who spent our inheritance travelling to 59 countries, and unlike her, I didn't buy a return ticket. I had the further good luck of tearing my Achilles tendon and potentially tearing the other, so now I have an excuse to stay in Austria, a constitutionally mandated 'neutral country' while the world teeters on something... well we just don't know, do we?
I told myself it was a 'work trip' for a book i'm writing, and I suppose it still is, but it's also a mid-life crisis trip, a trip taken under a bad health diagnosis and a trip made in forbodding that even if I survive, America as we know it may not.
I have never felt American, but I have spent whatever fraction thus allotted by my life trying to defend America from people who would say that it's a country deserving of nothing but shame. I have defended it against leftists who say that America is a country powered by nothing but genocide and exploitation, and I've defended it against rightists who claim that America is a country ruined by sponges and inner threats. America took my family in when we were thought the sponges and inner threats: America took us in when genocide pursued us all through the world for two-thousand years.
A large part of why I feel compelled to leave is my sense that they have now won: not either side, but both of them. For the voice of the center, there is no space. But far more important than the voice of the center is the voice of the individual, the iconoclast, the person with the courage to depart from norms. I feel now as though there is no space for me, and I'm sure you feel the same way.
But you're a Stevens: a Michigan WASP like Robin Williams, the daughter of a powerful auto executive. By even the standards of JD Vance, you ARE America. I don't know how long your ancestors were here: but I'd imagine it's more than 200 years. Your life is defined by it, your lineage, your privileges, your history, and even if you become one of us, you will always be American in a way 99% of Jews can never quite understand.
My mother's mother was a fetus on the very last train out of the Soviet Union. Even when my mother's family arrived in America, their lives were defined by the Soviet Union: first radicals who spent their lives embracing it, then anticommunists who devoted their lives to opposing it. My grandfather's father was beaten to death by a Nazi soldier in our ancestral shtetl: Bransk. His funeral was the final goodbye event for the entire Jewish community. My late father was the first Jewish child born in Bialystok, the nearest Polish city, and when he was born, his bris was a celebration for every survivor in the city. In between then, my grandmother's mother was shot by the Germans in a mass shooting after Jews were made to dig their own graves: according to Polish eyewitnesses she died while shouting the Shema: in Judaism, that was the tradition of the martyr's death going all the way from the Romans to the Crusades to the Spanish Inquisition. My grandparents were practically the only married couple in Poland who survived together: living in barns and fields on a steady diet of raw potatoes with my father's Tanteh (Aunt) Rochel. After the war, Rochel, a socialist, was shot by the far right Endex Party as a suspected communist collaborator: there are conflicting stories--one was that she was simply caught in a crossfire of the Polish Civil War, another is that she was rounded up and murdered in cold blood: given other statistics in Poland at the time, I worry the truth is still worse. And then there was my father's sister: seven years older and all of six years old at the the Shoah's end, dropped off when she was two or three at a convent where she learned the Ave Maria and Pater Noster, then standing next to my grandfather as he lead Rosh Hashana services for the shtetl survivors in 1945. By Yom Kippur, Tzipporah (Faygaleh) was dead from typhus. The only picture my grandparents had of her was at her funeral, lying in peace in her coffin. We only found it in a drawer as my grandparents suffered simultaneously from dementia.
We read that you want to become Jewish, and we don't particularly believe in cultural appropriation. If you become one of us, then everything about our people is available to you: the customs, the history, the laws, the mysticism, the language, the wisdom: but we're not just another American people like Episcopalians and Mormons: within Judaism is the concept of 'yichus:' the lineage of distinction that stretches back past living memory. A large part of the reason the orthodox insist on conversion taking years and years is because Yichus is just something you're born with: it's the inner experience that exists in the kishkes of every Jew with a family born into it: today we usually call that the 'limbic system.' And to acquire some of that inner experience is a process that takes years and years. A gentile does acquire the inner experience of Judaism overnight any more than a white male can acquire the experience of a queer black woman, and many Jews never acquire that wisdom.
Long before you seemed to define yourself by your relationship to us, I did not feel American. I felt a citizen of every country where Jews ever lived. I came to Vienna a week and a half ago, and when I got here, all I could think of was my late father, about whom you wrote to me movingly quickly the day he passed. All I could think is how I wished he could have seen this country he spent a good ten years of his life studying in school but refused to set foot in it. He spent a large part of his life wondering about this alleged Jewish paradise: what failed in this country's politics that this paradise for Jews so failed the citizens it once so valued?
In some ways, it's an unanswerable question. Politics, as I'm sure you know, is all chaos and luck. No matter how much you prepare, chance dictates it all, and the irrationalities of the day dictate the winners and losers; and those irrationalities form the basis of what we call history.
In other ways, it's all too answerable, and it's answerable by the breakdowns of the very norms and institutions that defended stability from decision to decision, year to year, generation to generation. Whether or not you were Jewish, you've had nearly 45 years of opportunity to read the Bible: and if you really read it, you'll understand what so many Jews don't these days: Jews right and Jews left.
History is not made by conspicuous heroes who take a stand against the day's prevailing trends. It's made by those quiet heroes who simply put one foot in front of the other and keep things going. Some of them are famous, some of them are eminent to those people who really know about Judaism, and the vast majority of them: we never know about.
Decisions like you made to endorse your would-have-been opponent are the kind of iconoclastic, individualistic decisions I feel Americans are suffocated from making in our generation, and after this, I imagine you feel very much the same way.

Perhaps I'm still too much a partisan in this extraordinarily partisan era, perhaps I'm too out of touch with what's necessary to keep a country going, but why does your decision fill my kishkes with such foreboding? Why does it feel so craven, so selfish, so 'goyish'?
Your fiance strikes me as a very Jewish type: the type whose hubris exceeds his Judaism, whose mind is filled with alleged concepts of Jewish peoplehood and self-defense, yet hasn't really read the Tanakh, and if he has, he hasn't read it with its lessons in mind.
Think of Netanyahu, think of Likud, think of the Republican party, then think of Shakesperean characters in the Bible like King Shaoul (Saul), think of Shimshon (Samson). Both put too much trust in their own judgement, both fancied themselves heroes, and the message is ultimately that they were idolators: they put their ultimate trust in something other than God: Sha'oul in himself, Shimshon in his love. Then think of the kings Hoshea and Yoshiahu (Josiah). Yoshiahu put too much trust in his own religiosity and did not consider the needs of those non-native Israelites he ruled, Hoshea put too much trust in the non-native Israelites. The end result of both was the same. Hoshea resulted in the destruction of the Kingdom of Israel, but Yoshiahu resulted in catastrophic defeats too. Yoshiahu's fanaticism can be said to have set up the calamity of Hoshea. Think of the Chronicles of Kings, the would have been lost book of the Bible. Think for a moment about why it may have been lost... The history of Jews, the history of Israelites and Judeans, is not an unbroken history of triumphs and massacres, yet someone in our history clearly wanted to frame it so.
The history of Jews is always being rewritten to be a story of victimhood and triumph. It is neither, it is a story of a people always struggling to do the right thing in complex situations, and the right thing, particularly in crisis, is to thread the needle: do the lesser evil that so obviously needs to be done, and live to fight another day.
On matters of love, trust your fiance. On matters of Judaism, trust neither him nor any of his neocon minions/minyans: they are selling a vision of Judaism that is flagrantly partial and self-flattering. We have been dealing with their type for three-thousand years: everyone from Bar-Kochba to Moses of Crete to Shabbetai Zevi to Jacob Frank. To be Jewish is not to bring attention to one's own heroism, and it is surely not self-defense. It is the simple, Talmud-like work of pragmatism: putting one foot in front of the other, making the practical accomodations to norms and customs and routine that carry one day to the next, agonizingly deliberating over the consequences of every practical question. Everything slightly antisemitic gentiles you heard about Jews being like pedantic Pharisees is right, only practices like phariseeism are what make the world stand afloat: not revolutionary progressives like Jesus, not PR men like Paul, not would-be warriors like Bar-Kochba and Akiva whose zealotry was delusional 2000 years ago, and is still delusional today.
The world is made go not because of them or their descendents: the world is made go by men like Moses: who negotiated between two irreconcilable poles: an angry, jealous God who often hated his people, and an angry, jealous people who often hated their God. It's made by men like Joseph, who suffers immeasurably on the path to power and waits for decades to take revenge on the close people who betrayed him, then dishes it out over a series of years only to compel their forgiveness in the end. It's made by Abigail, who abases herself before King David to save her family in disobedience of her husband. It's made by Nehamiah who secures a building permit rather than pray.
There are many who are going to call you a hero, others will tell you that what you did is a Chilul Hashem. It was neither, but it was a deeply goyish decision: made not in pragmatism but in ego dressed in heroism. Christians can afford such absolute values: a people threatened with annihilation never can, and we have survived by pragmatic compromises time and again.
Make no mistake, Abdul el-Sayed is an enemy of the Jews, not pro-Israel Jews, Jews. But he was caused by our supposed friends. Over and over again in Jewish history, we are the dhimmi, the schutzjuden, the protected minority, the model minority brandished as a weapon to the public to say 'you too could succeed like this if only your values were better.' We're given cover by absolute rulers who want merely to protect the upper class: raised to be the interface between ruler and ruled--the tax collectors, accountants, lawyers, doctors: the educated people who make a society go. But when the underclass rises up, and they inevitably do when times are lean, the upper class uses us as the perfect bait: we're thrown to the wolves, and the upper class survives.
The proper, Jewish decision, the decision of the true individual, was to endorse el-Sayed and work to undermine him from the inside. Even if it doesn't work, it has a better chance than if you step out in front and endorse a Republican that will only help brandish us as American schutzjuden. If both the American left and right prove one thing: there are no absolute moral values, and such short cuts lead society to ruin. There is only practical accommodation, and with enough of those, society lives on another generation.
All best wishes from your Jewish friend who is deeply worried about the Jewish company you keep.
They are not your friends.
Evan

Thursday, October 29, 2026

One Accident Away


I'm currently in Europe, and now that I have a torn Achilles I may be here a while longer. If I can travel, I'll be in some of the most pleasant cities on earth, if I can't, I'll be stuck in Vienna: poor me. Long as I'm here already, I'm not sure I ever want to leave.
It's not a moment too soon to get out of dodge, things are getting hairy everywhere, they may get hairy here. Part of what's scary right now is that we don't know where chaos will spread.
I feel like the only person in the world with good options right now. Sometimes, there are no good options, and this is one of those.
In Israel? I support putting the Arab parties into government, it's frankly not going to happen, but in spite of what I said yesterday, please don't think I'm doing it in any way but holding my nose. Not because they're Arabs, but because every representative is an antizionist, the vast majority of them are authoritarians, and haven't let go of the dream of ending Israel.
But the alternative is authoritarian too, and even more powerful.
I could be wrong of course, but Bibi won, it's almost a foregone conclusion at this point because nobody will work with the Arab parties, it's almost impossible to imagine. If I had to take a guess what happens next, Bibi does what he always does: he calls a new election, installing himself as a placeholder Prime Minister for the next year and a half yet again...
If Eisenkot's coalition understood what was at stake, and they don't, they would let the Arab parties in. The Arab parties would only wreak further havoc on the Middle East, deliberately undermining Israel's destruction and effectiveness in the way America's President does his own country (...), giving powers like Qatar and Iran means to dictate Israeli policy which would result in Qatar drawn into a war Israel's already waging in Iran, and every Israeli Arab viewed as a potential fifth column with treatment that resembles everything which happens in the West Bank or even Gaza.
And that's the smaller problem...
The bigger problem is delayed still further, Bibi and his followers grow still more delusional, and eventually, whether Bibi or whomever follows, somebody could so easily make a mistake like Putin did in Ukraine, a mistake from which there is no backing out, and the regional volatility puts the entire world at risk. If Israel is the cause of World War, no matter how provoked, there is another two thousand years of antisemitism.
Half of Jews persist in this manichean, paranoid delusion that there can be a militarized Jewish state forever, and behold the results. The problem is that so many people, so many people reading this, blame Israel and the Jews who support Israel for this state of affairs, and yet the entire rest of the world is in the same situation.
The European riots are, ultimately, small potatoes, something that happens every so often in countries that never quite figure stability out. France treats its riots as a tradition of national pride. But then, the riots came to Belgium, BELGIUM!
I have always believed that what makes people violent is not issues of survival but issues of humiliation: people trying to survive are too busy surviving to be violent for any reason but self-defense. People who feel humiliated are the ones willing to be violent on a mass scale.
The riots in Europe are not particularly violent, and yet the humiliations grow every year. If Europe has to pay for its own military, the social programs will shrink. We're constantly flooded with information about everything wrong with society. Most people can't afford houses anymore, so many have student loans. COVID caused severe disruptions to everyone's lives, and we all live in some low level fear of the next disruption.
If you relate to any of that, imagine what people younger than you feel. Now you understand why people riot, and why these riots are likely to grow in scale: perhaps exponentially. Are the lives of most gen-Z'ers truly bad? Well, no, not really. But their lives are worse than their parents, and they have to compare their own quality of life to the people before them, and that is a truly humiliating experience.
So then there's us...
...I don't need to talk about it. You know already.
In the wake of all that, people turn to answers. The answers may not be very good, but answers give you a reason to get up in the morning, and once a certain answer catches on, so does the opposition to that answer, and it becomes the defining question of the time. Once upon a time, that question was is 'salvation by faith' correct, or 'liberty, equality and fraternity' or national self-determination, or the worker's paradise, now the question is if there is an invisible system of oppression. More than any other question, your answer to this question: yes or no, defines your place on today's political spectrum.
If there is such a thing as 'systemic oppression', the best evidence is not systemic oppression, the best evidence is 'systemic division.' The fact that with enough time, so many societies seem to bisect into something resembling exact halves: Protestants vs. Catholics, royalists vs. republicans, Republicans vs. Democrats, Zionists vs. Anti-Zionists... Even if the raw number tally of either side is not exactly the same, it so often looks like with enough time, two irreconcilable sides in a conflict have something resembling exact parity in power.
All it takes is one accident. Accidents happen all the time, some seem intentional but few of them mean to cause widespread destruction they wreak. Forty-nine accidents can be repaired, but then there's the fiftieth, and that's a point of no return... That's Sarajevo, that's the Bastille, the defenstration of Prague, Fort Sumter, Pearl Harbor... that's the moment nothing can go back to the way it was, and everything we know about society is spat out like Listerine.
A divine accident may have put me in a place I've always wanted to be. I'm in a place I've always wanted to be in over every other place in the world, and miracle of miracles, it's a neutral country. I may never want to leave, but if things happen while I'm gone, I'll live with the same survivor guilt my grandparents lived with for getting out of a place like this, which used to be a place like ours.

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

A Message to Chaverim

 The Catholics say that God is in the votes when they choose a Pope. If God is in the votes, He is telling us the status quo is unacceptable, the liberal hawkishness of Mapai has outlived its usefulness by two generations, the appeasement of an Israeli Right that will never appease us has outlived its usefulness by at least a generation. The Founding Generation is dead, and a new founding generation will set priorities for the next lifetime.

We HAVE to evolve. The world's opinion MATTERS. We have a chance here of proving to a critical mass of the world that Israel is not an apartheid state, that we welcome widespread Arab representation, that we take the concerns of citizens seriously, that peace is a priority, and if the Arab parties want an unprecedented seat at the table with their concerns represented, they have to accept that the two state solution ought be revived. If a Jewish state steamrolls the concerns of millions of citizens, it can steamroll the concerns of further millions: Jewish millions.
Israel has proven that peace involves security, security involves armament and threat. A large part of the world has forgotten that and then willfully refuses to understand why dictatorships like Russia and China conquer half the world and an increasingly authoritarian Western right conquers the other half. The threat of w*r is always necessary to prevent war: both foreign war and civil war. Israel is the most trained country on earth, and a left and center that opposes the right will have their threat implied. Israel is going on a trend that in a generation or two could result in a Halachocracy.
Imperialism and totalitarianism are two sides of the same oppression, and there is no opposing one without opposing the other. Never again Auschwitz, never again the Belgian Congo, never again gulags or empire, never again robber barons and technological overreach. Work for fairer labor, work for fairer representation, work for security, and oppose EVERYONE who is an impediment. Serious people understand that peace and freedom and equality and security involves supporting it all and opposing all impediments, not just a few planks: solidarity matters, and so does patriotism, belief in the world matters, and so does belief in country.
Never again Likud, never again Hamas. That is the whole Torah.