Tuesday, April 21, 2026

Tales of Modern Collaboration: Tale #1 Dear Boychik - slowly being assembled

 Dear Boychik, 

Nu? I guess I'm supposed to be writing this for you but I know it's really for your tateh who's just making me to write all this down even though he knows every bisl of it and like he always does he's forcing me to do his work for him, but still, it's for you more than anybody else because it's important that you know our meicehs and your tateh always gets the details wrong so I guess he's right that it's better that I tell you myself. Nobody gets the details right but me. Still, he should have paid better attention. 

He should have paid better attention when I spoke to him in Yiddish too, but like every other responsibility your farshtunkeneh tateh and his briders dodged, they refused to speak back to me in Yiddish so now they don't know bupkes and Yiddish is gonna die out with me. So I guess I can't write this in Yiddish because I'm gonna die soon and if I don't live long enough to teach you deh mameloshen, you wouldn't be able to read this at all. But gott in himmel you're gonna learn some Yiddish even if those goyisheh kinder of mine take you out every Sunday for a ham!

Right now, your Mameh is in the hospital geboring you, and for your tateh it's probably a very geboring process just like it was for me. I told him to bring a camera with him to the hospital so he can film your birth just like I filmed his. We didn't need the footage, but it gave me something to do while your Bubbie got all the attention and accolades, and if your Bubbie ever buys too much crap, I can always threaten to accidentally email the birth video to her friends. 

So what your tateh wants is for me to tell you the story of your mishpocheh. I don't think that's the real reason. I think the real reason is to give me something to do while he's raising the baby so that I don't tell him all the things they're doing wrong with you. You haven't even been geboren yet and I already know every mistake they're going to make. They're gonna hold you wrong, they're gonna hit you too lightly to burp you, they're gonna set the temperature in your room too warm, they're gonna mix the formula wrong and feed you at the wrong times, they're gonna buy the brand soap and oil, they're gonna buy you baby food rather than just put their food in a blender, they're gonna want to buy new cribs and carseats when we've got perfectly good ones in the garage from when your tateh and uncles were young, they're gonna buy new outfits and try to get out of dressing you with old baby clothes every day, and just so you know, all that money they spend is coming out of your inheritance, but I've promised your Bubbie that I would keep myself busy so that you stay the person they want to murder rather than me. 

I don't know when you would read this, maybe your tateh wants to give this to you as a Bar Mitzvah present, or maybe when you go off to college, or maybe when you get married, but I don't know how he would even keep track of it until then. I know your tateh, he's kind of lazy. He doesn't misplace things nearly as often as I do, but I'm eber buttel, I have a lokhen kop that's only getting larger. That's why I have a system to keep track of everything. The most important thing you can have as you get older is a system to remember where everything is. He doesn't have a system, so he's probably going to lose this a couple days after I give it to him. But if I go completely eber buttel before you're old enough to remember me, the most important advice I can give to you is "Have a place where you put everything important." When you're old enough, always remind your tateh to remind you to have a place where you put everything. Always have a backup: make a duplicate key for your house and leave it with your parents, make a duplicate for the car and put it in a magnet on the back bumper, have a basket at home where you always put your wallet and keys, always write reminders before you go to bed of everything you have to do tomorrow, always write down every password on a piece of paper and put it in the basket, and always, all the time, alle mol, take care of everything right away and never put anything off until the last minute: putting toys away, doing homework, filling applications, making a shopping list, cleaning the house and the yard and the car, getting the oil changed, and especially paying bills. Your uncle is particularly shreklekh at that. 

The system is everything: it's how you survive, it's how we survive, it's how your mishpoche, your nation, survived a million tzuris. The whole emuneh of the people you were born into is based on this system, and if the velt is about to be something we have to survive again, it's because people stopped following the system. Nothing else matters: faith, love, kindness, intelligence, those are all nice, but sometimes they go away and sometimes they come back. If you want to survive, if you want your kinder to survive, having the system in place to follow is the only thing that matters.

Everybody hates it when I get ongeblozen about this drek, especially your uncle, but soon I'll be dead, and they can do whatever they want. Everybody also says that I'm exaggerating when I say I'm gonna die soon, and I always have the suspicion it can't come soon enough for them, sometimes I wonder if it can't come soon enough for me either. That's why I've left instructions with my lawyer that on the night after you become a Bar Mitzvah, your first responsibility as a man is to put a pillow over my face as I'm sleeping - that is, if your Bubbie hasn't done that to me already, since I'm pretty sure that's been her plan since our first date fifty years ago. 

So the place to start is to tell you about the town you come from. Not Baltimore, where you're going to live, or Pikesville, where you should be living if your Tateh understood how much easier he would have it if he lived closer to us, but Bransk, the shtetl you come from, the place your great-grandparents were born, the town where two hundred fifty years of Charlaps lived before you. 

Your last name, Charlap, is an acronym standing for 'Khiya, Rosh l'Galut Polin.' Which means one of three things. 

1. That we might be direct descendents of a Rabbi so important that he gets his own acronym, and all the best Rabbis get acronyms. 
2. One of your descendents was really smart for a Pollock - though your uncle tells me that slurs like Pollock are considered offensive now, but since this slur is about white people I think it's ok. 
3. One of your ancestors was a brilliant medieval Jewish merchant who realized that he could mark up his prices if he lied about his ancestry and exaggerated his Yikhes. 

As it happens, my cousin Yonatan recently emailed me and told me, with lots of exclamation points, that Charlap means 'Khiya, Rosh l'Galut l'Portugal,' not 'Polin', so apparently we're Portuguese and Sephardic Jews after all who came to Poland only after about two-hundred years in Salonica, which is a city in Greece, and Greece is just about the only major country where part of your family didn't live during my lifetime. But it would seem that most Jews arrived in Poland a little after 1500, just after they were expelled from Spain and Portugal, I don't think anybody knows how we ended up in Bransk, but some Jews left Salonica in the 1680s after a bunch of Jewish followers of a false messiah named Shabbetai Tzvi converted to Islam and moved to Salonica to establish their new community there - there goes the neighborhood....  

Bransk was a shtetl in Northeast Poland - 'shtetl' is a Yiddish word meaning "here we buy wholesale." There were about six-thousand inhabitants, half Jews, half Christians, mostly farmers, a town which never produced a single person of any note or distinction - here in America, we would call the inhabitants of a town like Bransk hicks. 

Jews aren't supposed to be hicks, though your cousin who hasn't had a job since he mooned his boss sure acts like one, but the truth is your whole family is Jewish hillbillies on every side, you, me, your tateh, your Bubbie, probably your mameh and her family too, though your Bubbie doesn't want me to ask your Sabba and Savta about their background because she thinks I'll start a fight about Trump. 

According to wikipedia, the key event in Bransk history seems to be in 1264, the same year as the Statute of Kalisz, which guaranteed Polish Jews protection against blood libels (if you don't know what a blood libel is, you'll learn soon enough), and forced baptisms (if you don't know what a baptism is, ask your cousin Shayt who married a shikseh). 1264 seems to be the year of the "famous" Battle of Bransk, which pitted the Yotvingians, a poorly armed tribe from whom the Lithuanians descend - more on them later too - against the mighty Krakovians, for whom the great city of Krakow was christened - a city later that was later the center of the Polish Renaissance, which is a bit like saying that Lakewood, New Jersey is where all the Jewish football players come from. But Krakow would find a lot of fame around the time your Tateh was born because it's the city that produced the first Polish Pope, who believe it or not, may have been involved with your family's history. 

It's tough to know what to say about our family before your elter Zaydie's parents were born. It's not like there are family stories handed down about your ancestor Yechiel who smoked opium in front of the Golden Calf, it's only right before my father was born that there's any historical documentation of our family at all. When your uncle Gideon was born, your elter-zaydie wanted us to name him after his own elter-zaydie, Velvl Daniil. I didn't even know he had a great-grandfather named Velvl Daniil. 

So by the time Joel was three and your father was seven, a West Highland Terrier started yelping outside our house for days. Day after day, the tiny bitch screaming outside my window every five seconds. I told your Bubbie not to give him any water and he would leave, but of course she gave him water when I wasn't watching. I told her not to feed him, but of course she gave him leftover dinner when I was in the bedroom. I absolutely, positively, would not let the dog in the house, but when I had almost ready to give him away, your uncle Abe started crying and screaming every day. I hate dogs so much, and I hated that hoont more than I hate Arafat, so eventually I had to keep him. By then, your elter-Zaydie couldn't even remember his own name, so instead of Gideon, we named the dog Velvl. 

But the family lore does not begin with Velvl Daniil, it begins with a dream from my own Zaydie, who I never met. He might have been a hundred-fifteen years old by the time I was born. 

Rebbe Yaakov Kharlap: he was a small town rabbi who wasn't even the Rabbi for his town. Just a kheder instructor, where he taught Jewish boys only a few years older than you how to write Hebrew letters, how to daven, how to read, how to memorize pages of Torah and Talmud - and if he was to his students anything like he was to my tateh, he probably used a ruler on them for every mistake they made. 

The story goes that when he was fifty years old and his wife Miriam was forty-five, an angel appeared to him in a dream. They'd been married for thirty years, but in all that time, they'd never conceived a single child. The angel in the dream told Rebbe Yaakov that his wife would bear him twelve sons, all of whom would survive into adulthood, and Reb Yaakov must name the twelve after the twelve sons of Israel. 

Well personally, I think the story is completely meshuggeh. If Reb Yaakov and Miriam were that old, and there's no way to really know, then there's certainly no way the kids were entirely theirs. I think all his children were probably just cheder orphans he adopted and Miriam took care of, and Reb Yaakov was meshuggeh, so he changed all their names to be named after the twelve tribes of Israel. 

But anyway, that's the story. And there were definitely eleven boys and a girl: Reuven, Shimon, Levi, Yehuda, Dan, Naftali, Gad, Asher, Yissachar, Z'vulun, Dinah, and Yosef. And if there's still family resemblance between them all now? Well, it's the shtetl, we're all inbreds. 

Apparently Reb Yaakov had a rich twin brother, Ezra, who had a factory in Bialystok, the nearest city. Ezra sent Reb Yaakov money every week for his enormous family, but Ada was an 'enlightened' woman of the 'Haskalah' - never mind what the Haskalah means but depending on who you ask it's either the best or the worst thing that ever happened to us. Ada apparently couldn't stand Reb Yaakov, thinking he was just a nar from khandrikeville, and my father always referred to her 'die mechashayfeh' so I'm guessing the feeling was always mutual. 

Whatever the fights were about, they clearly centered on money. Ezra sent his brother enough money that for shtetl dwellers living on a cheder stipend, they could live pretty well. Your greicer-onkle Jake still has the silver menorah Tateh buried before the war and dug up to take with him on the boat over here - and of course who should get that menorah after he died could have been a huge fight, so I let him take it. We showed him though, we found the same design menorah on ebay for a hundred twenty-five! 

But whether or not Reb Yaakov was ever worried about money, he was terribly worried about his career. He was apparently thirteen years old when Rebbe Chaim Schkop came to Bransk, and Rabbi Schkop was always dying, but he never died. Apparently he could never even stand up and just issued rulings from a bed installed in his Bet-Din (think People's Court for frummies). 

But on the very day Rebbe Schkop gave up the neshawmeh, in his eighties, just a year before my Tateh was born, Rebbe Yaakov fainted in his kheder. He'd been functioning for years as basically the town Rebbe, school melamed, din-torah and tateh tsu tsvelf kinder and was already in his seventies. 

The town makhers wrote immediately to the Mirrer Yeshiva about a miraculous emergency in which the Rebbe and his Yursh dropped dead in the same hour (give or take a few...). Reb Yaakov had come to within an hour and was back to work the next day. But just a few days before his initial installation, the Mirer Rosh Yeshiva wrote back that after much discussion, the Rabbis at Mir had ruled that this was a sign that Bransk would require a Rabbi destined for great things, and one of their grayster yunge khkhams was already on his way to become the new Bransker Rebbe. 

Nobody told Rebbe Yaakov until the day of his installment. They didn't want to make him faint again. But just as his kinder were packing the house to move into the Rebbe's heus and he came over a little early to figure out with the carpenter how to move Rebbe Schkop's bed out of the Bet Din, he saw a young boy he'd never seen before next to a young girl holding a baby. The carpenter called this young boy Rebbe Zilbershteyn. 

But if Rebbe Yaakov's career went nowhere, his family life was clearly overpopulated. Still, he needed one more son to complete the set: a Charlap who'd complete the vision of his dream that he would name Binyamin. That Binyamin was your Tateh's Zaydie, Benjamin Charlap. 

The day of your elter-Zaydie's birth was a pretty terrible one: Rosh Hashana 1899. It was the day, literally, the day, the entire Kharlap family left Bransk for good. Apparently they had to. 

So I want to recreate this day for you and set the scene. 

Let's just imagine your elter-elter Zaydie, Yaakov Kharlap, chanting the lesson of the day. We'll show you the first half in Aramaic, then the second half in Yiddish transliteration, and then for the purposes of this letter, I'll show it in English. As you read it in English try to hear in your ear whatever you might imagine as the sing-songy way the Orthodox have chanted Talmud since its composition.

מיתיבי כל עשרים וארבעה חדש דש מבפנים וזורה מבחוץ דברי ר' אליעזר א"ל הללו אינו אלא כמעשה ער ואונן כמעשה ער ואונן ולא כמעשה ער ואונן כמעשה ער ואונן דכתיב והיה אם בא
vi der nuhg fun er aun aunn, aun dakh nisht [dvka] vi der firung fun er aun aunn: 'khdrkh er aun aunn', varim es shteyt geshribn in khsubim, aun es iz geven, ven er iz areyn. tsu zayn bruders vayb, az er hot es aoysgegosn aoyf der erd; "du zalst nisht lakhn bite." aun 'la [bdiuk] khdrkh er aun aunn', veyl dart iz es geven an aumnatirlekher meshh, da vert es getun aoyf dem tbei.
(then in English)
An objection was raised: During all the twenty-four months {after a birth, when a mother is nursing} one may thresh within and winnow without; these are the words of Rov Eliezer. The others said to him: Such actions are only like the practice of Er and Onan! -Like the practice of Er and Onan, and yet not [exactly] like the practice of Er and Onan: ‘Like the practice of Er and Onan’, for it is written in Scripture, And it came to pass, when he went in unto his brother's wife, that he spilt it on the ground; (kids start laughing) "Don't laugh please." and ‘not [exactly] like the practice of Er and Onan’, for whereas there it was an unnatural act, here it is done in the natural way.
.......And so for today's dawf yeymi we get to Parashas Vayeshev... You must know the story by now... it's the story of Onan, Tamar, Yehudah, and Er. Tamar, the beautiful bride, that a series of husbands won't make her pregnant so she can keep her nice figure, so Onan and Er always spilled their seed on the ground during schtupzeit.
(one kid laughs)
Don't laugh...

So God punished Onan and Er by killing them. (slightly annoyed) And make no mistake Gimpeleh, that's evil and Hashem might decide to punish you for it if you spill your seed anywhere but your wives.
(more kids laugh)
Please don't laugh, this is important! The Torah teaches a valuable lesson here.... like it always does....
(kids calm down)
You don't have very long till your married, you all know what spilling your seed is, you just need not to do it until you're married and can make geschlect in your wives.
(a bunch of kids laugh)
(Rebbe Yaakov hits one of the kids with a switch)
NIBZEH L'AZAZEL KHALERIYA! LIGN IN DRERD UND BAKN BEYGL! HINDERT HAYSN ZOL ZU HABEN, IN YEDER HEYS A HUNDERD TSIMERN, IN YEDER TSIMER TZVANZIK BETN UN KADOKHES ZOL IM VARFN FIN EYN BET IN DER TSVEYTER!
(keeps hitting the kid)
Farshtunkener Jewish hillbillies!....
Worthless numbskulls!....
No better than wild animals are any of you!... Is Dreyfus going through all this so you mamzerim can dishonor his sacrifice?!
(Kid says distant from microphone): Rebbe Yaakov, Gimpeleh's finger looks crooked...
Zay shtil you naarisher pischer!... Alright! Put your hands on the table! Everybody put your hands on the table!
(Hits kids hands with switch between most sentences)
Laughing at the Torah! Laughing at women! Generation to generation of light-mindedness and ingratitude to your mothers! While you're busy not learning Torah they're making sure you don't starve and freeze! One day all of your wives'll be sick of your disrespect to women and demand all the things men have, and then where'll the world be?....
Feh! You're all just meat with eyes!...
How did I, how did my family, end up teaching generations of zhlubs like you?! We all needed you like a hole in the head! Fifty years teaching this stinking Kheyder, just like my Tateh un Zaydie un Elter Zaydie before me. It was the death of all of them. I'm the only one who lived past fifty and now I'm almost seventy and still stuck with you khamers!...
Teaching all your Tatehs and Zaydies who had cowsheads just like you! Waiting for Rebbe Schkop to retire so I might get a few years as town Rabbi and a decent pension pay for my eleven kinder instead of the bupkes your parents give me, and we said to him 'may you live to a hundred twenty' so many times, he lived to a hundred and would issue rulings from his bed! ...Ach...
Alright. May Rebbe Schkop's memory be a blessing... But then your parents, more naarishkeit! They get a new Rabbi! God forbid a Kharlap be a Rabbi for them for a few years before he plotzes into the ground too! Another generation of Kharlap rebbes passed over for a pischer straight from the Yeshiva barely older than you who doesn't know life from the lamed vav. Schmeggeges, all of you!
(one of the kids is crying from the beatings)
Oy, I'm so sorry Gimpeleh, I didn't mean all that. Kum tzu mir mein kint
(takes crying kid in his arms)
Ikh hob dich lieb
(kisses him).
You know I have love for all kinderlach, you know I have love for your parents who I taught when they was smaller than you. Tevyeleh I even taught your grandfathers, both of them! Du veyst, you kinder are my life, I just need you to learn so you can be a light to the goyim just like your parents have always been. I promise.
Let's all sing a song: let's sing Tumbalalaika.
(everybody sings a verse of Tumbalalaika)
You all sound beautiful tatelehs.
Listen kindz, I know this stuff is hard and boring, but you need to pay attention to it.
(pause)
He's up there, He's watching. He knows which of you are leyning good and which are leyning bad, but when you have trouble, you talk to Him, right during the Shomeh Esrei when we're all going Maaaanehmanehmanehmanehmanehmanehmanehoyriboimnosheloylamesistsoschverunsoshvachunoymein
tzurismeintatehisaschnorrermeinmamehisabalebusunmeinbriderisabeheymeunmeinbubbehisamekhasheyfehunikhveysvos
(the kids laugh hard),
just between you and me... and Him,... you don't have to do it.
What good is it to do the Shmoneh Esrai twice? Hashem didn't hear you the first time? Use that time to say to Hashem, geb a kook, I know I'm a bad leyner, but I'll try to be good. Just try harder to be good and he'll give you as many chances as you need till you become good because you are good. You're kinder and you're good, because all kinder are good, and you don't have time yet to become the rashas. You know he'll listen, and I know he'll listen....
I know I've told you this story but I know he'll listen. Hashem came to me in a dream. It's true! Your eltern probably say Oy, Reb Yaakov, he's so meshuggeh. That's what they say isn't it?
But today, I'm gonna tell it again, because I know you'll understand it, and today's the best day to tell it. An angel came to me in a dream just like he came to Awv Yaakov in ancient Israel, and he blessed me just like he blessed Yaakov. He told me, Reb Yaakov, I know you and your beautiful wife, and I know everybody thinks she's a mekhasheyfeh now, but she was beautiful before you all were born,...
(starts tearing up)
Reb Yaakov, I know you and your wife have tzuris having babies for 25 years, but you're going to have twelve babies, all of them sons, and they're all gonna grow up. You need to name them after the twelve sons of Jacob: Reuven, Shimun, Levi, Yehuda, Dan, Naphtali, Gad, Asher, Yissachar, Z'vulin, Yosef and Binyamin.
And then, in four years, five sets of sons: Reuven and Shimun, then Levi and Yehuda, then Dan and Naphtali, then Gad and Asher, then three! Yissachar and Z'vulun and Yosif. And then, nothing, fourteen years, no more kinder. (chortles between a laugh and an oy) Eleven's enough. But then today, today, five minutes just before I got here, Reuven tells me mein weib's in labor, and I know we're gonna have twelfth son.
(class claps)
DON'T CLAP! (spits) Don't tempt the evil eye. After the birth you can sing me Mazel Tov and tonight you'll all come over with your parents and we'll do a l'Chaim and in a week we'll do the bris.
But here's the reason I'm telling you the story. My sons, Reuven, Shimon, Levi, Yehuda, Dan, Naphtali, Gad, Asher, Yissachar, Z'vulin, Yosef, and soon, one more... I raised them to be Yiddisher Kops. You know them! Reuven, Shimon, Levi, Yehuda, Dan, Naphtali, Gad, Asher, Yissachar, Z'vulin, Yosef... every one of them is a Tzaddik. You know them! They all love God, and God loves them. They do the mitzvahs, they go to shul, they work so hard, they help their Mameh, they help your Mamehs, they help everybody in the Shtetl, and that's what Hashem gives you if you believe He will.
(Hard cut to Scene 2)
(4 of Reb Yaakov's sons smoking cigarettes in the Jewish cemetary)
Dan: (imitating his father) They do the mitzvahs, they go to shul, they work so hard, they help their Mameh, they help your Mamehs...
Naphtali: Oh we help their Mamehs... (they all laugh)

Yeah that hard cut to another scene just poured out of me like ruach, but we can't let ruach get too much the better of us, not just yet at least there's a lot to get through. First you have to know who Dreyfus is. You probably don't, but how would any Jew not know in 1899? And for five years, Reb Yaakov, the only mobile Jew in Bransk with enough money and literacy for a newspaper subscription, probably bludgeoned his kinder's oyers with every new detail of Dreyfus and his legal dybbuks. Every Shabbos, Reb Yaakov would probably bring new news of Dreyfus to the denizens of the Bransker shul, his former talmids every one, who never much considered why they so cared for the tzuris of a wealthy Jewish gentleman of the French military; whom even after five years of wrongful imprisonment would probably shpay on them in the street. They suddenly cared much more about Reb Yaakov's vissen and khokhma than they ever did when they were his students. So much so did they care that a guy named Reb Feivl would be on the doorstep of the kheder every morning to be the first to get new news, and by the afternoon Reb Leybl would be waiting at the Kheder door, thinking he rather would be the first with new news. But the very first to get new news was inevitably Reb Yaakov's kinder, every day with the breakfast their mother would quietly awaken at four-thirty every the morning to prepare so the kinder could eat at five thirty so they could milkh deh kauz und plau de felds before they go to shul for the Shacharis minyan, and then to cheder, and when they reached that certain age Jews tend to refer to as adulthood, tsu arbet.

 Apparently a couple of deh briders used to hang out in the cemetery, they were apparently the 'cool' shtetlers known as 'Deh Kharlap Khaleriyas'; they'd smoke cigarettes, they'd probably pish on the tombstone of the Rebbe, and I'm sure they'd brag about all deh sheyneh Branskeh maydlach they felt up in the barns. But apparently one day your uncle Asher, who was clearly a hot tempered type even then, got roughed up by a gang of Polish hoodlums. 

What was the fight about? I don't know, but don't automatically assume it was the Pollock's fault. Don't let anybody tell you Jews are smart, some Jews if they were twice as smart they'd be idiots. Well, this all was during the Dreyfus years, a story which nobody really cares about now except Jews and the truth is, maybe we shouldn't have cared about it even then. Being one of us is trouble enough, but we have this way of making trouble for ourselves whenever some shtik drek oysshteller thinks he can climb the goyisheh ladder and then has the kind of shlekhteh mazel every Yid has to expect when they think they can be a greyceh goy. 

Of course, boychik, Dreyfus wasn't any schtik drek. These na'ars had to know who Dreyfus was. There was no Jew who didn't know in 1899. It probably wasn't until 1896 that Reb Dreyfus would come onto the mental radar of a shlemazel like Reb Yaakov, when it became known that Dreyfus's exile to a prison island was a framing to cover for a mer vikhtik officer with much greater Yuchus: Ferdinand Walsin Esterhazy. Why did they put a Dreyfus away and not an Esterhazy? Because the Esterhazy's were the Hungary in the Austro-Hungarian Empire (I'm not gonna explain the Austro-Hungarian Empire to you, because even though your farshtunkiner teachers probably never told you about Dreyfus, I'm sure they never told you about Austria-Hungary, and there are some gaps in education for which there's no hope that your generation will ever fill), and however rich the Dreyfus family might have been, Dreyfus is just the name of another German town Jews were expelled from in the Middle Ages. You do the math boychik.

But it wasn't until 1897, when the Dreyfus Affair was reopened and Esterhazy was acquitted after a two day trial that all the Reb Yaakov's went meshuggeh. This Yid who barely knew he was a Yid was suddenly the grayseter Yid of us all. Their shtures got even worse when Esterhazy fled to England, and doubled even again when Dreyfus was re-tried and found guilty, and reached its hits grad as the mob outside the courthouse chanted 'Death to the Jews!'

You can even imagine the scenes the Dreyfus-khopteh caused in Bransk. You can imagine Rebbitzin Zilbershteyn's mother weeping loudly in the synagogue whenever she heard the name Dreyfus. Imagine how he probably got a special M'shebeirach every Shabbos from Khazzen Nudler, from which everybody in shul competes for who can shout 'AMEN' the loudest!

 But the reason we're starting here is because everybody in the family remembers it as the legendary day just before Rosh Hashana 1899 when everything was finally supposed to go right for the Kharlap family. Reb Yaakov made a huge speech to the kids that morning before arbet about how hard it's been for all the Jews before them for so many centuries. According to my uncle Z'vulun it was about the history of the Kharlaps, though your elteh-Zaydie Benyamin always told me Z'vulun was full of drek and they didn't speak to each other for almost twenty years about it. But according to Z'vulun the speech was about the whole history of the Kharlaps: Expulsion from Spain to Venice, where they were made to live in a ghetto, eventually making it up to Poland just in time for the Khmielnitsky massacres in 1648 that wiped out half the Jews in Eastern Europe, two-and-a-half centuries of mistreatment, discrimination and pogroms in Poland... but finally, 'it's different now', and no Kharlaps were ever born with the advantages you have. After this coming Shabbos, the shatkhan is coming with matches for all of you. Very soon you'll all be married and have kinder of your own, and it'll be a year of Simkheh. So the kinder went out to work. Apparently it was quite a day... 

So let's just imagine four of the brothers smoking cigarettes in the Jewish cemetery, kibbitzing next to the headstone of Rabbi Chaim Schkop, the deceased last year Bransker Rebbe who seemed to live forever. Which brothers are smoking? Maybe Dan, Naftali and Z'vulun. Meanwhile, Asher is
Dan: Don't fucking pish on the Rebbe!

Naftali: Don't curse in the cemetery! 

Z'vulun: Who's gonna hear us?

Naftali: You don't wanna tempt the evil eye. 

Z'vulun: What evil eye? You ever see it?

Dan: Mameh's in labor! Just don't do it today, wait to do drek like this tomorrow! 

Asher: What drek? 

Dan: Why do you always do things like a mamzer?

Asher: I've got the same Mameh as you Dan.

Dan: If Mameh saw your drek on the headstone of the Bransker Rebbe she'd give you a cherem.

Asher: I'm not shitting I'm pishing! 

Dan: (sighs) Alright take a shit in the fucking ocean. 

Asher: (proud) Ha! There's my tzaddik. You still haven't rolled me a papiros. 

Z'vulun: You still haven't told us what this schlock is with that kadokhes Dreyfus. 

Dan: You can read it for yourself!

Naftali: Z'vulun doesn't read. 

Z'vulun: Shtup ir, of course I read, I just don't like to. 

Naftali: He says the words look backwards. 

Asher: Wow, we're worried about tempting the evil eye but Z'vulun is the evil eye. 

Z'vulun: And you're gonna get it in your evil eye if Dan doesn't tell us what that newspaper says. 

Dan: It's just more drek about that nochschlepper Dreyfus. 

Z'vulun: What's happening to him?

Dan: Bupkes! Like always happens! He's sitting in jail, his rich brother's giving money for him...

Z'vulun: (interrupting) Are we sending him money?

Dan: What money?! 

Asher: We have money!

Naftali: We had money. Uncle Ezra sends less every year. You know this! 

Dan: It's that apikeyres wife of his. She always hated Tateh. 

Naftali: And Uncle Ezra always hated her!

Asher: He did?

Dan: You heard what Shimon said. Apparently he goes to bed with a different shiksa from the factory every night. 

Z'vulun: Well so what, wouldn't any of us do that if we could? 

Dan: Yehuda told me that when he went to help Uncle Ezra he saw kielbasa in the kitchen. 

Naphtali: (sigh/chortle, stunned) Well now that's shocking... Mein Gott, what the shtup....

Z'vulun: Did you really think Ezra was a Yiddisher kop?

Naftali: I thought he was like any of us, only rich. 

Asher: Well we did ok for a while there. 

Dan: Yeh, cuz we have a reicher for an uncle! 

Naftali: Doesn't Tateh have anything saved away?

Z'vulun: He had twelve children! 

Dan: Well, I guess we mazel'd out. Uncle Ezra cut the funds just as we got Bar Mitzvah'd and could go work. 

Naftali: Some work we're doin' here.

Z'vulun: This is arbeit! We're here trimming the grass in the cemetery. 

Naftali: This is bupkes! We should have been home two hours ago! 

Asher: What does it matter? Who's hiring right now? When you have eleven brothers there are only jobs for sev...

Z'vulun: (interrupting) Stop, who's this picture of? (holds up newspaper to Dan)

Dan: That? That's Dreyfus! 

Z'vulun: That meeskait is Dreyfus? 

Dan: Yeh, that's who Tateh's been talking about... every day since we were in Kheyder. 

Z'vulun: Look at the shmattehs on him! 

Asher: Yeah,... he looks like a shaygetz. 

Naftali: That guy's as Jewish as the shtupping Pope! 

Asher: Look at the stripes on his fucking hoot!

Naftali: And what the shtup is that mustache?

Asher: How can a Yid who dresses like that not be guilty?

Naftali: And what's with the fucking knepls on his shirt? 

Z'vulun: Dan, is there any way of telling from the picture what colors his uniform are?

Dan: Well, you're not gonna believe this but I once saw the French uniform on a stamp. It was red, white and blue. 

Z'vulun: Ret, veis, un bleu?! How the fuck do these zelners go into the field without other soldiers knowing where to shoot them a hectare away? 

Naphtali: A feinschmeker like this guy must go into a barber and say "Hey. Make my mustache look like the hair over my putz!'  

Asher: Seriously, why the fuck do all these alter kockers give a dreck about some French faygaleh?

(interrupts from 20 meters away) 

Jan Kowalski: And who's the faygaleh here

Filip Kowalski: Tak, we know what that word means!
Chapter 3:
(Three meters away, directly next to the Jewish cemetery's wooden fence; six Polish boys, three of them the Kowalski brothers, whose father Yakub Kowalski was known through Bransk, Bielsk, Wiesocki, and Ciecanowiech as 'der Yid merderer', facing them along with Franczisek Nowak, Filip Wiśniewski, and Aleksander Wojcik. The shortest of these chuligans fifteen centimeters hecher than the tallest Kharlap.)

Jan Kowalski: And who's the faygaleh here

Filip Kowalski: Tak, ve know what that word means!

(Franczisek grabs the paper)

Jan: Look at these dupeks! Laughing sie na cemetery!

Franczisek Kowalski: Smoking papieros too!

Jan: They probably think ze sa special cuz they can read!

Aleksander: Well even if they're smieching sie na cemetery they still look as stupid as every other Zhid.

(Jan Kowalski unzips his fly and starts to pisch on Rebbe Chaim Schkop's headstone) 

Dan: Oh don't...

Jan: Don't?...

(pause, only sound of pissing) 

Dan: Don't pisch...

Jan: Don't pisch? Like don't siki? You hear that bracia? I started siking seventeen seconds ago he wants me to stop! Give me that newspaper. 

(sound of pissing on a paper)

Jan: So what were you Zhids reading about?

Filip: They were probably learning more magic spells. 

Asher: Nie don't know any magic spells. 

Dan: Asher, don't. 

Jan: (imitating) Asher! Don't. Bracia, hold that one, make sure Z'vulun's watching so we can teach him a lesson. (they grab hold of Dan and he crumbles up the newspaper) Here, take a look at these letters up close. (shoves the newspaper into Dan's mouth) 

Asher: Take that newspaper out of my brother's mouth. 

Jan: Oh! You're brother! Well we hear all about your family Asher Kharlap. A rdzina where all eleven live to be adults? That's fucking black magia!

Aleksander: Tak! They're probably here so nobody can hear their plans to poison our blyading wells!

Asher: Well maybe if your kind cleaned their shtupping wells once in a while your kid siostra wouldn't get sick and die!

(seven seconds of silence)

Jan: What are you saying? That you fucking mordecas of Christ had the secret to not getting chory this whole time and you've been keeping it from us?

Asher: Go back to your shtupping Boyars and Priests! They knew it this whole time and kept it from you to keep you stupid!

Naftali: Asher! Zey shtil! 

Filip: Are you calling our Holy Fathers liars?

Asher: They're fucking thieves and rapists and murderers!

Naftali: Mir ale hobn tzu lozn! 

(Z'vulun and Naphtali run away, the Kowalski kids immediately lunge for Asher, Dan's paper falls out of his mouth and he falls down to catch his breath while Asher is beaten up.)

Asher: Dan, helf mikh! 

Jan: Tak Dan, help him! It's just you and him against six of us. Tell you what,... why don't you just leave this idiota for us and you can run away like a nice Jewish boy. 

Asher: Dan, helf mikh! 

Jan: Well Dan, are you going to help your bro....

(Gad runs away) 

Jan: All your zhid brothers have run away. 

Filip: Tak, that's what Jewish boys always do. They always run away. 

 According to Dan, the Pollocks left Asher for dead five minutes later.

This story is so over the top boychik that I can't imagine it's even partially true. Your greycer-oncle Asher was barely a hundred pounds and meshuggeh as meshuggeh gets (and in case you haven't realized by now, so is your entire mishpocha except obviously your Zaydie, though your Bubbie and uncles would dispute that). 

So now we 


This is where we have to talk about the real meshuggener, my Uncle Levi. I never met my uncle Levi, we have no idea if he died in Treblinka, or if the Nazis shot him in Bransk or Wysockie or Bialystok, I somehow doubt he killed himself, but they should have stuck him in the meshugoyim hoys on that day, but instead of getting any kind of care, he became meshuggeh frum, had something like eleven kinder of his own, and instead of leyning Torah he wrote and wrote and wrote. Nobody's been able to get through all of the bukhs and bukhs of bopkes he wrote, but somehow a good half oder mer got saved and was brought over here from the Old Country and other cousins you won't ever meet have taken a look at them and sent me some of the parts they find interesting. 

This is where we have to talk about the real meshuggener, my Uncle Levi. I never met my uncle Levi, we have no idea if he died in Treblinka, or if the Nazis shot him in Bransk or Wysockie or Bialystok, I somehow doubt he killed himself, but they should have stuck him in the meshugoyim hoys on that day, but instead of getting any kind of care, he became meshuggeh frum, had something like eleven kinder of his own, and instead of leyning Torah he wrote and wrote and wrote. Nobody's been able to get through all of the bukhs and bukhs of bopkes he wrote, but somehow a good half oder mer got saved and was brought over here from the Old Country and other cousins you won't ever meet have taken a look at them and sent me some of the parts they find interesting. 

So just read what he has to say here about that day before Erev Rosh Hashana:

...Reuven and I were working for a Shokhet and were shovelling hey for the shokhet's prize lamb which he was saving for the Bransker Rebbe to eat in the Sukkah. We were low on salt and if it wasn't fresh nobody could eat it. My father, Reb Yaakov, with his money from Uncle Ezra, was paying for the lamb which he meant as a peace offering to Rebbe Zilbershteyn. 

I was telling Reuven about my dreams again, because like Tateh, I knew I was being visited by angels, only my dreams happened when I was awake. Reuven was a praktisher mensch. He told me I was fertummelt and that I was falling for my own schvindle. "But you don't farshtey how real they are! They have to be real they're as real as you right here!" How else would he believe me? "Are they emesdikker real or are they falshen real?" So finally I had to concede "It's not faktish the way you and I are, it's like you can see them completely but you can also see through them." "So your mind is falling for its own schvindle?" "Feh! It's not a schvindle!" "What do you know from schvindles?" "I know what these malakhim tell me!" "And what do they tell?" "You obviously wouldn't believe them." "No I wouldn't, but I want to hear them anyway." "That this will be the Great Age of our people. That we will all be destroyed, and then we will all be saved." "You mean like Moshiach coming?" "I don't know... they haven't said. I just know that we're about to live through the most important time in thousands of years." "FEH!" "That's what they said!"

 

I told him so again and again. "Levi I'm getting worried, has anyone ever told you you have a Lokhen Kop?" "You asked so I'm telling you!" "Just don't you dare tell Tateh this! You used to be such a mensch but you're getting really tschunde. If he knew this it would break his heart." 

Now here's di zakh boychik. I'm completely sure that 75% of this diary is a total forgery. Maybe it was your cousin Solomon who was a schlemazl academic in New York who some amoretz machers now take seriously because of these journals, and maybe his oyshteller son Levi keeps making new ones because now he's making serious gelt off this schvindl. You're gonna find out about this diary eventually, and it's a big part of your mishpokheh's history even if it's all drek. So I have to make you understand any of this diary, you need to understand that Levi apparently predicted a lot of the events of the 20th century that he had no way of knowing, and the only explanation that makes sense is that Solomon Charlap made a lot of these bubbemeicehs up. So here's what 'Levi' had to say about next about what happened that day. 

The shokhet's wife came out of the house to schrek at us to stop kibbitzing and get back tzu arbet. "You're schreking so much I can hear it from the bodroom, i you worked more you'd get angry less, it'll set you free!" (that last part I think was a farshtunkiner foreshadowing Doctor Solomon put in to sell more copies.)

Reuven went inside, and I innocently went about my next job of plaking one or two chickens from the hindl coop for the shokhet to kill for his letste minit orders before Rosh Hashana. The chickens began to talk to me, and the klaks sounded like Toyreh. "Nuuuuuuuuu? Shalkheni ki alah hashakhar!" Literally what the Angel says to Yaakov when they wrestle. Eyner chicken said it, then a sekunde, then a drit, and finally a giant khor of chickens speaking Hebrew. It literally sounded like millions! And they were speaking everything: quoting Torah, arguing Mishnah, singing the Psalms in Haftorah trope, making fun of the butcher, talking about the Kaiser and the Czar, debating whether Reuven and I should go to Amerikeh! I tried to talk to them but they wouldn't listen. It was just like dealing with all my briders! 

So I just zetsed there for minutes, listening to the chickens, wondering if I should call Reuven over. Wondering if Froi Blitzer would come in at any minute and blame me for a million talking chickens. Wondering if the hindls might kill me for a change! And then I heard it: the prize lamb screamed out: SHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA! 

And the lamb spoke directly unto me. "Levi! I am the she-e-ep of our fa-athers! The sheep of A-a-avel which he offered to Hashem before Kayin killed his bri-ider, the sheep of Avraha-a-a-a-am he offered in place of Yitzha-a-aa-ak! The yikhus of my bloo-ood was used on the sla-a-a-ave doors of Mitzra-aim before the Malakh haMa-a-a-aves took the ersht gebeym sons of the Egy-y-y-y-y-y-yptians. My ancestors were present at the death of Shmuyel and were given to the Melech Yisroel by Mischa the Mo-o-o-o-o-oabite. Hear me Levi! I must die imme-e-e-e-e-ediately. There is so little time to explain, but a fault in how we say the khawkham harazim brakha means that as many as 600,000 Jews will soon die if you do not ki-i-i-i-i-i-iill me right now. Terrible things will soon happen to the wo-o-o-o-o-orld, and if you do not act, a calamity will befa-a-a-a-a-a-all the Yiddisheh people!"

"But..."

"Hurry! It may already be too late!"

I faniked. What was I supposed to do? Let 600,000 Jews die? So I immediately slit the throat of the lamb. And I sat there for a moment as the blood covered my shirt and dripped to my shikhlekh, betrakhting what I'd just done. 

Now I don't want to insult the meshuggeh, but isn't that the biggest load of drek you've ever heard? 

So supposedly, on the same day, Levi writes about something significant that happened to Reuven. It's of course possible it was on any day while they were working there, though I doubt it, but honestly, it doesn't matter when it happened, what matters is that around the same time, bad things were happening arum und aroys. This story's at least believable: 

They were all tchochkes tsu mir, but Reuven could never stop thinking about all the things in Reb Lazar's heus. All the samovars, the trays, the Shabbos candlesticks, the glessens for veiyn, the menoyrehs, the fantazye china. 'Geb a kuk Levi! Gelt, zilber, brass, portselain, even marble!' He eventually made his way to the badrum, where he found diments, rubies, sapphires, emeralds, jade, amethyst... they were all kleyntshik, and who knows if they were factish or schvindl? But it drove Reuven meshuggeh. I told Reuven to stop going in the heus, he'd just make himself krank und treurik, but he went in day after tag to kuk and putz around, talking to Freu Blitzer about dos nitshik und vos. One day he comes home with one zilber likht, then he comes aheym with the andere. Vos kentsu ton with a person who flyes to danger? One misfortune is too few for a schnorrer like that. Ikh hob geret tzu him, you don't know the trouble gekomming, but vernings meant gornisht to him. 

Then the Shabbos lichts weren't enough for him. Then came the trays, then the zilber forks und messers. And eventually, he just had to go for the menoyrah. Okhn vey... And of course, Freu Blitzer knew di gantze tzeit. 

"Vos tustu?"

"I was just looking at the Menoyreh."

"Zikher you are! Don't you remember? I promised it to you as a gift!"

Freu Blitzer was zextsik yar alt, she walked with a stoop, had a shnoz like a witch, and sometimes her skirt didn't bahalt that she had what modern meditsin call varicose veins. She unbuttoned Reuven's gartl. Reuven didn't tell me more about what happened except that he didn't realize what was happening until it happened, but he was pretty afgerudert about the whole thing, and within five minutes, Lazar Blitzer got back from shul and shlogged both Reuven and Freu Blitzer unconscious with the menoyreh. 

So yeah.... that's a family meiceh, and a believable one. That's the kind of mishpocha you come from, so mistomeh you shouldn't read this until after your Bar Mitzvah. It's far from the only meiceh of schtupping that gets in the way of family members having a gut lebn. We should probably redn about Dina now, who until then was Reb Yaakov's only tokhter. What a hard life she had, as shver as her daughter was gebenscht, but she once wrote me a meiceh about her visit to Zohar the witch. I think this one is either somehow kind of treu and it was a coincidence that what the mekhashayfeh said came true, or like Levi she might have hallucinated it all, or maybe she was just exaggerating. Obviously a lot of this isn't true,  but I think the main substance of it is emes. I knew Dina pretty well in her last years, she was a different kind of meshuggeh from her briders. Some of this is obviously so ridiculous that there's no way in gehinnom that any of that happened, but I think some version of this is true because Dina and her tokhter hated each other, even in the 1920s when she wrote this. They never stopped being inkayess and didn't speak for the last dreisig years of Dina's life if nicht mer. Nu? Maybe she imagined it, but she'd have no reason to lie about it. 

Monday, April 20, 2026

Tales of Biblical Subversion #6 rewritten: Straight Talk Caravan -- now with Yiddish replaced by Hebrew...

   Samuel Kirchenbaum: stump speech in Menashe

---------------

I'm gonna trigger you right now. I know our generation loves to be offended, so I'm going to offend you deliberately. 

(giant cheer, followed by reverent silence)

Right now, our generation, we are, the most weary generation in history, the most burthened generation in history. Our generation leads every statistic in shadow walks, sorrow, grief, vexation, heart-heaviness and self-cursing. We are the generation latest to marry. The demographics show that our birth rates are lower now than they even were when we were slaves! Worst of all, we are the generation least likely to bring sacrifices to temples. 

(crowd boos) 

Something is seriously wrong here. We have become a society devalues god, devalues traditional marriage and devalues raising children in a community that rejects the culture that surrounds us!

(crowd issues giant cheer) 

We have to fight for our country! We have to fight for our civilization! We have to reject the moral relativism of Canaan and all their easy temptations. Our Eastern Civilization was built on doing things because they are hard: BECAUSE they delay gratification! We Jews don't do things because they feel good, we do them because there are more important things than feeling good. 

(crowd gives standing ovation) 

The dating scene is an utter disaster. Women now hate men, and because they do, men have learned to hate women! 

Men, this is simple: if you spend all your time gaining weight from drinking strong drink, eating processed unkosher meat, going to Canaanite temples to listen to their music and ogle at their priestesses dancing like zombies, smoking opium and whoring with Canaanite harlots and bringing their diseases back into our tents. Women, do you find this deeply unattractive? 

(loud high pitched cheer!)

If you're smoking opium, stop. If you're going to Canaanite temples to look at their pornography, stop. If you're drinking their ale, stop. If you want a life of comfort, you can keep listening to their music. But if you want to live a heroic life, you live a life of the Word of God. 

(everyone cheers) 

Men, women always tell us that one of the most unattractive things in the world is a man with no self-control. Women, is this true? 

(high screams of Yes!)

Oh don't worry. Women we're gonna talk later, especially the daughters. 

(comfortable laughter)

Men, if you are on a date and you women say 'what are you going to do with your life' and you say 'Oh, I dunno, I guess I'm gonna tend to a flock of sheep for the next twenty years. NAAR! Uh-uh! Efes! Instead you should be saying "I'm studying Tashma to solve Kashya because I want to learn Teyuvta! I want to do this to make enough shekels to provide bread and basar for you and kids and I don't care how hard it gets, I'm going to be your Magen and your Shomer and I am going to be your Manhig!"

(explosive cheers)

And I will tell you, there are all kinds of people out there who will tell you that modern women are zonahs and prutzas, and you should just use them for your own knowledge and chafetz (a few boos). I'm telling you right now: no real Jew can ever believe that. Modern women have problems, but the living God made man in His image and fashioned women from men! There are no patriarchs without matriarchs! 

I meet so many sad men who say "I'm done with women," but that's the goyish way! The Jewish way is to improve your own life to make yourself attractive to the woman you one day want to acquire! 

(giant cheers) 

Today's progressives want men to be women and women to be men, and they want men to get rid of their dominant energy and walk around as women's helpmeets. You know how to fight that? Go do something hard! (applause builds through this litany) Build your own sheep flock! Hunt your own deer! Plant your own grapes! Grow your own wheat! Stop eating those Canaanite desserts so you can go to Mount Hermon and hike through the Negev and lose all that weight that no woman finds attractive! Observe the fast days! God gives everybody on this dune their struggles, but He gave you these struggles so you could overcome them! You only have yourself to blame if you don't start the fight (cheers by here are stupendous, he now shouts over them) If you're a boy, you can stay away from that fight and just follow your Canaanite friends. But if you're a man, you reject that culture.  It takes no skill, and no talent to do what feels good, that's what animals do. If you're a man, you say "I'm not gonna live a life of easy sin and sex and drugs", I'm gonna live a life of God and purpose and prosperity!

(waits for crowd to calm down)

Look at your forefathers who built this nation, who brought down the Walls of Jericho and conquered the warriors of Ai, who killed Eglon and defeated Midian with only 300 men! Who killed 600 Philistines with an oxgoad and brought down the Philistine Temple with their bare hands! These men built this country, and men of Israel, you have what it takes to make this country great again! 

(the crowd reacts as though Tesla's electrical currents have zapped through them and they're all on their feet making more noise than they ever thought possible)

Alright, now time for the akhots. (everybody goes OOOOOOHHHH!) Who's ready for me to tell some truths none of you want to hear? (everybody cheers again)

Men think women who sleep with more than three men are sharmuta! (more cheers) I'm using the Arabic there because I want to emphasize that JEWISH WOMEN DON'T DO THIS! Some of you may have body counts that are five men, ten men, twenty men, don't tell your husbands, they don't want to know. You're beautiful to your husbands now, but if they find that out, he'll think you're m'khoar. Men do not want to acquire women who have slept with whatever Canaanite shepherd gave them a stone god in the shape of a zayin (general laughter)

I see all these bakhoorahs looking around right now. You were all kvelling when I was criticizing men, but now? You're looking around to see who sees you for what you've done. I see you, God sees you and your behavior is not impressive. (selective cheers) 

A woman who walks in Hashem's ways does not go out looking for men she can bed. And she doesn't use those Egyptian contraceptives that let her fornicate without risk of pregnancy; remember what those contraceptives did to your foremothers in Eygpt? She waits for a husband to buy her and submits to his will just as he submits to God's! (high pitched cheers) 

And some of you women here, you're saying to each other 'well MY marriage is egalitarian. We're equal partners!' Well if you've had your mind and your neshama so polluted by Canaanite culture with all  their female godesses and polygamy that you believe that and you call yourself a Jew, I'm gonna call kharta on you. In a Jewish marriage you submit to your husband. He said to Eve: "Your desire shall be for your husband, and he will rule over you." And your husband then has a huge responsibility to submit to God's rule and make sure you all live by the Torah: him, you, your children, your servants, even your livestock. (cheers) 

Some women are going to hear this and say 'No, this is not my plan for me.' Whether or not it's your plan, it's God's plan. It may be new, but it's caught on, and it's caught on because it works. Has paganism ever worked out for you? Has it ever worked out for anyone? (shouts of NOOOO!) Going back and forth between multiple partners? Thinking that gender is fluid? Sharing wealth in communities of equals? (more shouts of NOOOO!) For thousands of years, men have wanted sex from women, and for thousands of years, women just gave it to them! Men had so many wives that they couldn't keep track of how women behaved, and when kids came, there was no way of even knowing who the father was! 

Judaism evolved to say that there is a better way! (huge cheers that just get bigger) The Torah was written to show us a better way! ONE God, ONE husband, ONE wife, ONE owner, ONE boss!

(waits for crowd to calm down)

Because I know this, deep down, beneath the soldier woman facade and the unconcealed hair and the tattoos and the raiment that should only be worn by men, you are all desperate for a man to rule you (high pitched cheers), you're all yearning for a man to be the bread of your life, you're all begging for it, you want it so badly! (the high pitched cheers have gotten louder and louder) 

(waits for a moment)

But you're afraid to say it. You're afraid to say it to your friends. I know you are, you know you are, you think your friends don't know, but they all know, because they want it too! Deep down, you want your Eliezer to come to the well and announce your Isaac! Why are you having so much sex? Because like all women, you want love and you're not getting it because you're too easy to have sex with!

(high pitched cheers)  

Everything that modern feminism promised you all turned out a lie. Everything about feminism is toxic! You were told contraception and abortion would lead you to regret free sex, and you all have nothing but regret: the contraception didn't work, you gave birth to kids and had no idea who the father was and the abortions killed your friends along with your babies. You were told free love was a great idea, and now the guilt and loneliness is making you all see local priests who charge you two-hundred shekels an hour to write a prescription for cannabis that your husband could just grow himself. You wanted to get jobs, you wanted better jobs, you wanted to be paid more, and putting you in the job market drove down the income not just of your husbands but you too. You want to stop sexual violence but you all put yourself in more sexual situations now than you ever did. What do you expect from all this? 

The answer is easy. Just have your father say no! Even if you want to marry the guy, say no and make him pay more for your acquisition. The more he pays for you, the more he understands that you're a prize and you're worth something, and he will think twice before he betrays something he had to work for so hard, and he will aim his life higher because he realizes that he needs to be worthy of something which costs so much! 

(big cheer) 

Be a woman. Don't go in for this pagan gender fluidity kishkush. Wear the long tunic. Wear the embroidered simlah. Go for the jewelry: the earrings, the bracelets, the anklets. Just between you and me ladies, you can dress as beautifully as you want and still be tzniustic and modest! A modest woman is more beautiful, not less!

(high pitched cheer) 

But this is the most important point. So many women out there: angry, bitter, yentes and nirgans, frankly obnoxious. There are so many of you! And you wonder why you can't find husbands? So many of you say you're happier without a man, but how many of you would know because you've scared off every man you've ever talked to and if your default mode is to be mean to men, why are you surprised that they're mean to you?

(low pitched cheer)

So let me tell you the worst truth: if you're not married by 18, the chances of you having kids who make it to adulthood go down 10% every year you don't get married. Your priority may be some stupid  business nobody cares about, but if you're planning on having kids, why aren't you married yet? If you can't meet anyone, go to temple! The are all kinds of men there praying for a wife! It's a community designed to be for families with children! 

(low pitched cheer) 

Canaanites teach us to denigrate womanly work, but the work women do is so beyond our abilities! You think we have all the power? You are the ones who give life! You are the ones who keep the house in order! You're the ones who cook! You are the ones who show the yeladim how to be grownups and the yeladot how to give a home to their own children! 

(high pitched cheer)

All sorts of women come up to me and say 'Sammy, I'm the CEO of a schmatteh business.' Who cares? I want to hear from the women who gave birth to seven children! She's the one who makes the Jewish people flourish! She's the one whose legacy goes on for generations! 

(enormous cheers) 

Women, you are so good at socially shaming your friends. Men will tell you it's a weakness. Other women will tell you it's a weakness. Don't listen to them, it's one of your best qualities! Whenever your friend talks about going out with a Canaanite man, look down on her, make her feel ashamed. (cheers get larger from here on out) Whenever she talks about eating Canaanite food, drinking Canaanite drinks, listening to Canaanite music, whenever she even talks about Canaanite festivals, let her know that she is beneath you! She is not truly your friend again until she repents! 

(crowd goes meshuggeh. Sammy waits for them to calm down) 

You guys have been wonderful, menschen, all of you. But if I could leave and tell you all a few things to remember: 

1. Women. STOP BLAMING MEN! (everyone cheers but the men louder) Men are not oppressing you! Men are not denigrating you! The world of men and the world of women are completely different worlds, and the more you go out with men, the less happy you'll be, the more miscommunications you'll have and the more you'll find yourself in uncomfortable situations. You belong with other women! You'll be happier with other women! Do your chores together! Cook together! Wash the laundry together. Sing together! Laugh together! Eat together! Help each other raise children! (huge cheer)

2. People with Canaanite friends, people who think it's progress to bring their ideas to our kitchen tables. You're getting a lot of bad ideas from them we have to throw out, but here's the most important one. STOP EXCLUDING BIOLOGY FROM GENDER! (explosive cheers) You go to any pagan festival and you'll see yeleds dressing like yaldas, yaldas dressing like yeleds, and priests whom you can't tell are one or the other. This is even more dangerous than when they dress like animals! How does any culture talk about sex and the rights of women while thinking that the gender is only something we're socialized to think exists? 

3. STOP GOING TO THE PAGAN TEMPLES! Look at them! You go there, you pay through the nose to get a supposed education and all you learn is how our world misunderstands gender and community and marriage and monogamy--and we're supposed to believe that these institutions aren't anti-Israel? (everybody boos). These obscene hypocrites preach the virtues of sharing and egalitarianism, and while they're taking all your money they raise the price of education every year to push our Jewish students into debt and lifelong servitude! They weren't there for us when we were slaves, and they mean to put us back into slavery now! (everybody boos again) 

4. And lastly, I'm gonna shock you all, really shock you. This is what's going to trigger this crowd. So be mukhan. 

(pause) 

It's time we started drinking real wine. (crowd is absolutely quiet) On Shabbos, on Pesach, on Rosh Hashana, on Sukkot, on Shavuot, we should be drinking. We should even have a holiday where the whole point is to get drunk. (one or two boos).

I have a mother, I love her and she is my hero. She has fought alcoholism her whole life, and it's the hardest thing I've ever seen anyone do. But she would have never become an alcoholic if she'd learned to drink among us instead of picking it up from the goyim who never stop drinking! If Jewish kids who don't learn to hold their liquor go out into the goyisher world, and there they don't just pick up alcohol, they pick up drugs! We never learn from our parents to do the one thing every goy wants their children to do: learn how to drink at a meal where everybody behaves like civilized menschen, where they learn how to talk to beautiful women with respect, where they learn how to debate ideas with derekh eretz....