Wednesday, March 30, 2022

Missa Solemnis and Fidelity to the Score

 


So here's a discursion on score fidelity...
And before I begin I want to be clear here, I understand the vital importance of fidelity to the score, so much so that at times, like literally all of us in classical music, I have been guilty of overestimating its importance, so this is not in any sense whatsoever meant as a slap on anybody's wrist - though there's a guy on the conductor listserve who's incredibly obnoxious about score fidelity and seems unable to listen to any conductor who isn't Toscanini or Levine. How's that working out for him these days?...
I was discussing with a very good friend about the Missa Solemnis and what it takes to get the printed page into the concert hall. The problem with the Missa Solemnis is, it's almost literally impossible to realize Beethoven's vision: it's just too hard. Look at the markings in the Gloria.
Lots of conductors make a giant showboat of the 'In Gloria Dei Patris' fugue, and make their choruses strut their stuff. The problem with that is threefold:
  1. The choir has to keep something in the tank for the Credo, which is a mammoth showpiece, and after the Gloria they're mostly exhausted.
  2. There's no sense in having fast choral counterpoint in two movements, by the Credo fugue, the chorus would have already proven that's what they can do, and the shock is gone.
  3. So... in the Gloria fugue, Beethoven writes Allegro ma non troppo e ben marcato. It's clearly supposed to be in a march tempo. Perhaps a parade just like the Turkish section of Beethoven 9, but whatever it is, it's not supposed to be nearly so fast as many, MANY conductors take it.
The problem is that the next section is probably supposed to be a showboat section for soloists. Beethoven is a notorious inferno for vocal soloists. Beethoven writes both poco piu Allegro and in cut time. It's possible that Beethovne meant only a little faster, as the score clearly states, but given that Beethoven's clearly trying to build wild excitement, the only other possibility is to look at the time signature. He writes Poco Piu Allegro but also 2/2, cut time. In other words, MORE THAN TWICE AS FAST. The final change to Presto, in context, is not nearly as dramatic as the change from choral to solo.
It should be obvious, this is a nearly impossible marking to realize, and has always been, but very few performances realize both sections in the markings. In just about every performance, nobody tries. It's either Maestoso the whole way through the In Gloria Dei Patris, or it's Molto Allegro the whole way through, and even the Molto Allegro performances are never as fast as Beethoven seems to want the solo section.
On the other hand, in the Credo, the beginning is Allegro ma non troppo, and nearly half the performances are much too fast for that marking (though some are also quite a bit slower). But then, you get to the big moment when the chorus ascends: Et Ascendit. Once again, the tempo goes alla breve, and it's almost impossible. Gardiner, who steamrolls through every slow marking, comes closest, Bernstein comes fairly close too, and is at least much better about following Beethoven's tempi.
But there's no question, THIS is the moment when the chorus is demanded to step on the gas. But then... once again, the et vitam virturis is supposed to be relatively slow and subdued, and many, many performances are much too fast, and already showing off. It's only when we get to the second fugue that the chorus is supposed to do a series of virtuoso runs and from which Beethoven demands equivalent coloratura techniques to any trained Baroque opera singer. It is almost impossible to realize, but Beethoven clearly wants one and ONLY one moment when the entire chorus goes berserk, because he knew that 50% of choral rehearsal must go into exactly that passage.
This is not how nearly everybody plays it. They either keep things at a comfortable speed, or they do virtuosity everywhere. Neither is what Beethovne wanted, and neither captures nearly so much diversity of expression as his own idea. But... such is the world, and just about everybody who sells themselves a personally in touch with the composer's vision is wrong about it. My interpretation could certainly be wrong, but that's OK, because I've reconciled myself to it.
A score is, quite literally, a theory. Like a mathematical proof, it is a schematic that does not give information on any practical, real life application. And like legalistic originalism, a reading of the law itself means nothing without stare decisis - the practical wisdom of precedent, where the same law runs through decades of interpretations that are tailored to the specifics of that performer's capabilities.
As a listener, I see the concept of score fidelity as a temptation that, when viewed in only two dimensions, can ruin music appreciation and robs music of its ability to increase a listener's quality of life. But at the same time, without the score, classical music is nothing. A score is both the basic fact of classical music, and the millstone that squelches individuality in performers, alienates thousands of musicians from classical music and tens of millions of listeners who can't tell any difference between one performer and the next.
I've come to look to insistence to score faithfulness more forgivingly than I did even five years ago; just like in every other genre of music, not every sway to the winds of fashion is worthwhile, without a grounded conception, we get cult-like devotion to insipidity - and whether that insipidity is Teodor Currentzis, Taylor Swift, or President Trump, that is a sad state of affairs where people look to the cult leader to shut their brains off, not turn them on.
A compromise HAS to be reached, so one of the ultimate qualities I look for in performance is musicians who, while not necessarily following the score letter by letter, are clearly engaging deeply with it - taking the markings into consideration, interpolating them into their own interpretation that neatly tucks away the limitations of human fallibility.
One example: Bluebeard's Castle is a work that's meant an enormous amount to me since I was a teenager who thought himself quite literally unlovable. When I began to follow the score, I realized the only person who truly followed the score is Dohnanyi - who is an evolutionary miracle of music who's able to follow the most complicated markings as though there's no trouble at all. But I also noticed that some of my favorite conductors who directed very famous versions of Bluebeard: Kubelik, Fricsay, Kertesz, were not even considering the markings, and to me, it sounded that way: their readings were flat on the page (there are many other performances where Kubelik and Fricsay come closer than nearly anybody, try Tchaikovsky 5...). On the other hand: Sawallisch, Dorati, Solti, Rattle, Ivan Fischer, they all clearly kept the markings in mind, and while they didn't follow them totally, they clearly tried their best to direct fallible forces to something that approximated the printed page, and in each case the results were incredibly exciting.
There are certain things which under no circumstances can be captured by markings on the page. The metronome marking for the Hammerklavier Sonata's opening is notoriously impossible, literally unplayable until today's human computers. Unless you are a human automaton, squelching any human feeling at all, a performance of the opening in Beethoven's conception has to allow for danger, wrong notes, dropped notes, lots of rubato, and lack of rhythmic coordination. A Beethoven score cannot possibly tell you which technical sloppiness is permissible and which isn't, but in any performance, some things are never meant to be controlled. To control them is to play God, to view music as no different than automation and clocks. No musician may do that without it ceasing to be music, and no musician has the moral right to even try. Anybody who believes they do is asking to be exploited by charlatans. 

Tales from the Old New Land - Scene 2 first half Middle Draft

(Hard cut to Scene 2)


(4 of Reb Yaakov's sons smoking cigarettes in the Jewish cemetary)

Gad: (imitating his father) They do the mitzvahs, they go to shul, they work so hard, they help their Mameh, they help your Mamehs...

Asher: Oh we help their Mamehs... (they all laugh)

Dan: Hey, roll me one too. 

Naphtali: You sure? Every time I roll you a papiros sound like you're gonna huss out Rabbi Schkop! 

Asher: How do you know we didn't ground der Rebbe into tabacco?

Gad: His headstone's right there! Why don't you ask him? 

Asher: Why don't I? 

(hear a fly unzip, Asher pishes on the Rebbe's headstone)

Dan: Oh don't fucking pish on the Rebbe!

Gad: Don't curse in the cemetery! 

Naphtali: Who's gonna hear us?

Gad: You don't wanna tempt the evil eye. 

Asher: What evil eye? You ever see it?

Gad: Mameh's in labor! Just don't do it today, wait to do drek like this tomorrow! 

Asher: I'm not shitting I'm pishing! 

Gad: Alright take a shit in the fucking ocean. 

Asher: (proud) Ha! There's my tzaddik. 

Dan: You still haven't rolled me a papiros. 

Asher: You still haven't told us what this schlock is with that kadokhes Dreyfus. 

Dan: You can read it for yourself!

Naphtali: Asher doesn't read. 

Asher: Shtup ir, of course I read, I just don't like to. 

Naphtali: He says the words look backwards. 

Dan: Wow, we're worried about tempting the evil eye but Asher is the evil eye. 

Asher: And you're gonna get it in your evil eye if you don't tell us what that newspaper says. 

Dan: It's just more drek about that nochschlepper Dreyfus. 

Asher: What's happening to him?

Dan: Bupkes! Like always happens! He's sitting in jail, his rich brother's giving money for him...

Asher: (interrupting) Are we sending him money?

Dan: What money?! 

Asher: We have money!

Naphtali: We had money. Uncle Ezra sends less every year. You know this! 

Gad: It's that apikores wife of his. She always hated Tateh. 

Dan: And Uncle Ezra always hated her!

Naphtali: He did?

Dan: You heard what Shimon said. Apparently he goes to bed with a different shiksa from the factory every night. 

Gad: Levi told me that when he went to help Uncle Ezra he saw kielbasa in the kitchen. 

Naphtali: (sighs, stunned) What the shtup....

Dan: Did you really think Ezra was a Yiddisher kop?

Naphtali: I thought he was like any of us, only rich. 

Dan: We did pretty well for a while there. 

Gad: Yeh, cuz we have a reicher for an uncle! 

Naphtali: Doesn't Tateh have anything saved away?

Dan: He had eleven children! 

Naphtali: Well, I guess we mazel'd out. Uncle Ezra cut the funds just as we got Bar Mitzvah'd and could go work. 

Gad: Some work we're doin' here.

Dan: This is arbeit! We're here trimming the grass cemetery. 

Gad: This is bupkes! We should have been home two hours ago! 

Dan: What does it matter? Who's hiring right now? When you have eleven brothers there are only jobs for sev...

Asher: (interrupting) Who's this picture of? (holds up newspaper to Dan)

Dan: That? That's Dreyfus! 

Asher: That meeskait is Dreyfus? 

Dan: Ye, that's... who Tateh's been talking about every day since we were in Kheyder. 

Asher: Look at the shmattehs on him! 

Dan: Yeah, he... looks like a shaygetz. 

Gad: That guy's as Jewish as the shtupping Pope! 

Naphtali: Look at the stripes on his fucking hoot!

Gad: And what the shtup is that mustache?

Naphtali: How can a Yid who dresses like that not be guilty?

Dan: And what's with the fucking knepls on his shirt? 

Asher: Dan. Is there any way of telling from the picture what colors his uniform are?

Dan: Well, you're not gonna believe this but I once saw the French uniform on a stamp. It was red, white and blue. 

Asher: Ret, veis, un bleu?! How the fuck do these zelners go into the field without other soldiers knowing where to shoot them a hectare away? 

Naphtali: Even a feinschmeker like this guy shouldn't go to a barber and say "Make my mustache look like the hair over my putz!' 

Asher: Seriously, why the fuck do all these alter trombeyniks give a dreck about some French faygaleh?









Tales from the Old New Land - Opening Monologue - Final Draft

 


Rebbe Yaakov Charlap: (opening until explosion should be as dull as possible)
(in Talmudic leyning chant, first half in Aramaic, then in Yiddish, then the whole thing in English)
מיתיבי כל עשרים וארבעה חדש דש מבפנים וזורה מבחוץ דברי ר' אליעזר א"ל הללו אינו אלא כמעשה ער ואונן כמעשה ער ואונן ולא כמעשה ער ואונן כמעשה ער ואונן דכתיב והיה אם בא
vi der nuhg fun er aun aunn, aun dakh nisht [dvka] vi der firung fun er aun aunn: 'khdrkh er aun aunn', varim es shteyt geshribn in khsubim, aun es iz geven, ven er iz areyn. tsu zayn bruders vayb, az er hot es aoysgegosn aoyf der erd; "du zalst nisht lakhn bite." aun 'la [bdiuk] khdrkh er aun aunn', veyl dart iz es geven an aumnatirlekher meshh, da vert es getun aoyf dem tbei.
(then in English)
An objection was raised: During all the twenty-four months {after a birth, when a mother is nursing} one may thresh within and winnow without; these are the words of Rov Eliezer. The others said to him: Such actions are only like the practice of Er and Onan! -Like the practice of Er and Onan, and yet not [exactly] like the practice of Er and Onan: ‘Like the practice of Er and Onan’, for it is written in Scripture, And it came to pass, when he went in unto his brother's wife, that he spilt it on the ground; (kids start laughing) "Don't laugh please." and ‘not [exactly] like the practice of Er and Onan’, for whereas there it was an unnatural act, here it is done in the natural way.
.......And so for today's dawf yeymi we get to Parashas Vayeshev... You must know the story by now... it's the story of Onan, Tamar, Yehudah, and Er. Tamar, the beautiful bride, that a series of husbands won't make her pregnant so she can keep her nice figure, so Onan and Er always spilled their seed on the ground during schtupzeit.
(one kid laughs)
Don't laugh...

So God punished Onan and Er by killing them. (slightly annoyed) And make no mistake Gimpeleh, that's evil and Hashem might decide to punish you for it if you spill your seed anywhere but your wives.
(more kids laugh)
Please don't laugh, this is important! The Torah teaches a valuable lesson here.... like it always does....
(kids calm down)
You don't have very long till your married, you all know what spilling your seed is, you just need not to do it until you're married and can make geschlect in your wives.
(a bunch of kids laugh)
(Rebbe Yaakov hits one of the kids with a switch)
NIBZEH L'AZAZEL KHALERIYA! LIGN IN DRERD UND BAKN BEYGL! HINDERT HAYSN ZOL ZU HABEN, IN YEDER HEYS A HUNDERD TSIMERN, IN YEDER TSIMER TZVANZIK BETN UN KADOKHES ZOL IM VARFN FIN EYN BET IN DER TSVEYTER!
(keeps hitting the kid)
Farshtunkener Jewish hillbillies!....
Worthless numbskulls!....
No better than wild animals are any of you!... Is Dreyfus going through all this so you mamzerim can dishonor his sacrifice?!
(Kid says distant from microphone): Rebbe Yaakov, Gimpeleh's finger looks crooked...
Zay shtil you naarisher pischer!... Alright! Put your hands on the table! Everybody put your hands on the table!
(Hits kids hands with switch between most sentences)
Laughing at the Torah! Laughing at women! Generation to generation of light-mindedness and ingratitude to your mothers! While you're busy not learning Torah they're making sure you don't starve and freeze! One day all of your wives'll be sick of your disrespect to women and demand all the things men have, and then where'll the world be?....
Feh! You're all just meat with eyes!...
How did I, how did my family, end up teaching generations of zhlubs like you?! We all needed you like a hole in the head! Fifty years teaching this stinking Kheyder, just like my Tateh un Zaydie un Elter Zaydie before me. It was the death of all of them. I'm the only one who lived past fifty and now I'm almost seventy and still stuck with you khamers!...
Teaching all your Tatehs and Zaydies who had cowsheads just like you! Waiting for Rebbe Schkop to retire so I might get a few years as town Rabbi and a decent pension pay for my eleven kinder instead of the bupkes your parents give me, and we said to him 'may you live to a hundred twenty' so many times, he lived to a hundred and would issue rulings from his bed! ...Ach...
Alright. May Rebbe Schkop's memory be a blessing... But then your parents, more naarishkeit! They get a new Rabbi! God forbid a Kharlap be a Rabbi for them for a few years before he plotzes into the ground too! Another generation of Kharlap rebbes passed over for a pischer straight from the Yeshiva barely older than you who doesn't know life from the lamed vav. Schmeggeges, all of you!
(one of the kids is crying from the beatings)
Oy, I'm so sorry Gimpeleh, I didn't mean all that. Kum tzu mir mein kint
(takes crying kid in his arms)
Ikh hob dich lieb
(kisses him).
You know I have love for all kinderlach, you know I have love for your parents who I taught when they was smaller than you. Tevyeleh I even taught your grandfathers, both of them! Du veyst, you kinder are my life, I just need you to learn so you can be a light to the goyim just like your parents have always been. I promise.
Let's all sing a song: let's sing Tumbalalaika.
(everybody sings a verse of Tumbalalaika)
You all sound beautiful tatelehs.
Listen kindz, I know this stuff is hard and boring, but you need to pay attention to it.
(pause)
He's up there, He's watching. He knows which of you are leyning good and which are leyning bad, but when you have trouble, you talk to Him, right during the Shomeh Esrei when we're all going Maaaanehmanehmanehmanehmanehmanehmanehoyriboimnosheloylamesistsoschverunsoshvachunoymein
tzurismeintatehisaschnorrermeinmamehisabalebusunmeinbriderisabeheymeunmeinbubbehisamekhasheyfehunikhveysvos
(the kids laugh hard),
just between you and me... and Him,... you don't have to do it.
What good is it to do the Shmoneh Esrai twice? Hashem didn't hear you the first time? Use that time to say to Hashem, geb a kook, I know I'm a bad leyner, but I'll try to be good. Just try harder to be good and he'll give you as many chances as you need till you become good because you are good. You're kinder and you're good, because all kinder are good, and you don't have time yet to become the rashas. You know he'll listen, and I know he'll listen....
I know I've told you this story but I know he'll listen. Hashem came to me in a dream. It's true! Your eltern probably say Oy, Reb Yaakov, he's so meshuggeh. That's what they say isn't it?
But today, I'm gonna tell it again, because I know you'll understand it, and today's the best day to tell it. An angel came to me in a dream just like he came to Awv Yaakov in ancient Israel, and he blessed me just like he blessed Yaakov. He told me, Reb Yaakov, I know you and your beautiful wife, and I know everybody thinks she's a mekhasheyfeh now, but she was beautiful before you all were born,...
(starts tearing up)
Reb Yaakov, I know you and your wife have tzuris having babies for 25 years, but you're going to have twelve babies, all of them sons, and they're all gonna grow up. You need to name them after the twelve sons of Jacob: Reuven, Shimun, Levi, Yehuda, Dan, Naphtali, Gad, Asher, Yissachar, Z'vulin, Yosef and Binyamin.
And then, in four years, five sets of sons: Reuven and Shimun, then Levi and Yehuda, then Dan and Naphtali, then Gad and Asher, then three! Yissachar and Z'vulun and Yosif. And then, nothing, fourteen years, no more kinder. (chortles between a laugh and an oy) Eleven's enough. But then today, today, five minutes just before I got here, Reuven tells me mein weib's in labor, and I know we're gonna have twelfth son.
(class claps)
DON'T CLAP! (spits) Don't tempt the evil eye. After the birth you can sing me Mazel Tov and tonight you'll all come over with your parents and we'll do a l'Chaim and in a week we'll do the bris.
But here's the reason I'm telling you the story. My sons, Reuven, Shimon, Levi, Yehuda, Dan, Naphtali, Gad, Asher, Yissachar, Z'vulin, Yosef, and soon, one more... I raised them to be Yiddisher Kops. You know them! Reuven, Shimon, Levi, Yehuda, Dan, Naphtali, Gad, Asher, Yissachar, Z'vulin, Yosef... every one of them is a Tzaddik. You know them! They all love God, and God loves them. They do the mitzvahs, they go to shul, they work so hard, they help their Mameh, they help your Mamehs, they help everybody in the Shtetl, and that's what Hashem gives you if you believe He will.
(Hard cut to Scene 2)
(4 of Reb Yaakov's sons smoking cigarettes in the Jewish cemetary)
Dan: (imitating his father) They do the mitzvahs, they go to shul, they work so hard, they help their Mameh, they help your Mamehs...
Naphtali: Oh we help their Mamehs... (they all laugh)

Tuesday, March 29, 2022

Cantelli Cosi and the problems of performing Mozart

This is.... by some distance, the only recording I've ever heard that does complete justice to Cosi Fan Tutte. Of the three great Da Ponte operas, Cosi is the stupidest, but it's also Mozart's most beautiful operatic score. It's an impossible work: it's a celebration of the nihilism of love, simultaneously trivial and profound, beautiful and cynical, hateful and loving, exploitative and forgiving. In the face of an emotional burden that large, how does sitting through any performance not become a chore?

Last night I listened to Fritz Busch's '51 Cosi, and bad sound aside, it was extraordinary in a way I'd never heard Cosi be. It was not all that well sung except by Jurniac and Bruscantini, but it was suffused by grace, a thing of pure divinity that floated down a river of pure music. Of course, there are other Mozart recordings suffused by that delightful transcendence, but I'm not sure there is a Cosi that is quite like that.
The real music is not stuff we hear. Real music is made in the overtones, from which our amygdala responds physiologically on a level at which our ears are not really aware. The lower brain is where our emotional response is processed. You can't explain why the Busch/Jurniac Cosi is amazing, but you can feel it.
But even in the bad sound of the Cantelli, you can HEAR the upper octaves. Forget the precision here, which is breathtaking. Just listen to the blend between singers and orchestra. On the stage of La Scala where every major conductor from Toscanini to Abbado has tried to rein in singer egos, a singer as egotistical as Elisabeth Schwarzkopf matches perfectly to blend with the timbres of instruments, and the singers even go to great pains to blend their vibratos with each other. This is the 'gesamtkunstwerk' opera is always said to be, but never is. How different might opera be today if Cantelli took a different plane?
From Busch, it's as though we're listening to pure divine grace, but from Cantelli, it's as though we're experiencing divine revelation, as though the music is revealing to us the true world behind the world from which music originates. I don't know if we mortals are supposed to hear music on a level this deep without going mad, it's like eating from the Tree of Knowledge, but I do know that it's an unforgettable experience.
But my general problem with Mozart performance is still that, for all the change, we still think of him as Mr. powdered wig when he wanted to storm the Bastille. The real Mozart is one step from Beethoven, and most of his soul is what music was soon to become. While Mozart is not hypomanic like Beethoven, he is so much more than exquisite. His music is as vulgar, and cynical, and as disturbing as the personality in his letters. There's a place for the exquisite in Mozart, but ONLY when he writes 'mp' or 'p' or 'pp,' and then he shocks you, again and again, with giant fortes. He is the master ironist, and particularly in his greatest masterpieces, whatever Mozart sounds like he's expressing, he is usually expressing the opposite. He's Rousseau in music: you think he's completely comfortable in the world of rococo courts, but the truth is he wants to blow the whole society up. The WHOLE POINT of such exquisite beauty is that he views the world of powdered wigs with withering contempt. The slow music is usually taken 50% or more slower than Mozart's scores, the fast music 50% or more faster, and the dynamic contrasts... 200% smaller. The proper tempi change the entire pacing of works. The way he's played, you'd think that Mozart took a look at court life and thought everything was just fine.
Viva la liberta! 

Old New Land Podcast Play 1 - Scene 1 - First Half - Final Draft



Rebbe Yaakov Charlap: (opening until explosion should be as dull as possible)

(in Talmudic leyning chant, first half in Aramaic, then in Yiddish, then the whole thing in English)



מיתיבי כל עשרים וארבעה חדש דש מבפנים וזורה מבחוץ דברי ר' אליעזר א"ל הללו אינו אלא כמעשה ער ואונן כמעשה ער ואונן ולא כמעשה ער ואונן כמעשה ער ואונן דכתיב והיה אם בא


vi der nuhg fun er aun aunn, aun dakh nisht [dvka] vi der firung fun er aun aunn: 'khdrkh er aun aunn', varim es shteyt geshribn in khsubim, aun es iz geven, ven er iz areyn. tsu zayn bruders vayb, az er hot es aoysgegosn aoyf der erd; "du zalst nisht lakhn bite." aun 'la [bdiuk] khdrkh er aun aunn', veyl dart iz es geven an aumnatirlekher meshh, da vert es getun aoyf dem tbei.

(then in English) An objection was raised: During all the twenty-four months {after a birth, when a mother is nursing} one may thresh within and winnow withou; these are the words of R. Eliezer. The others said to him: Such actions are only like the practice of Er and Onan! -Like the practice of Er and Onan, and yet not [exactly] like the practice of Er and Onan: ‘Like the practice of Er and Onan’, for it is written in Scripture, And it came to pass, when he went in unto his brother's wife, that he spilt it on the ground; (kids start laughing) "Don't laugh please." and ‘not [exactly] like the practice of Er and Onan’, for whereas there it was an unnatural act, here it is done in the natural way.

And so for today's dawf yoymi we get to Parashas Vayeshev... You must know the story by now it's the story of Onan, Tamar, Yehudah, and Er. Tamar, the beautiful bride, that a series of husbands won't make her pregnant so she can keep her nice figure, so Onan and Er always spilled their seed on the ground during schtupzeit. (one kid laughs) Don't laugh (slightly annoyed). So God punished Onan and Er by killing them. And make no mistake Gimpeleh, when you spill your seed anywhere but your wives, that's evil and Hashem might decide to punish you for it. (more kids laugh)

Please don't laugh, this is important! The Torah teaches a valuable lesson here.... like it always does.... (kids calm down)

You don't have very long till your married, you all know what spilling your seed is, you just need not to do it until you're married and can make geschlect in your wives.

(a bunch of kids laugh)

NIBZEH L'AZAZEL KHALERIYA! LIGN IN DRERD UND BAKN BEYGL! HINDERT HAYSN ZOL ZU HABEN, IN YEDER HEYS A HUNDERD TSIMERN, IN YEDER TSIMER TZVANZIK BETN UN KADOKHES ZOL IM VARFN FIN EYN BET IN DER TSVEYTER! Farshtunkener Jewish hillbillies!....

Worthless numbskulls! No better than wild animals are any of you!... Is Dreyfus going through all this so you mamzerim can dishonor his sacrifice?!

Kid says distant from microphone: Rebbe Yaakov, Bontsheleh's finger looks crooked... 

Zay shtil you naarisher pischer!... Put your hands on the table! Alright! Everybody put your hands on the table!

(Hits kids hands with switch between most sentences)

Laughing at the Torah! Laughing at women! Generation to generation of light-mindedness and ingratitude to your mothers! While you're busy not learning Torah they're making sure you don't starve and freeze! One day all of your wives'll be sick of your disrespect to women and rebel against you. And then where'll the world be?....

Feh! You're all just meat with eyes!... 

How did I, how did my family, end up teaching generations of zhlubs like you?! We all needed you like a hole in the head! Fifty years teaching this stinking Kheyder, just like my Tateh un Zaydie un Elter Zaydie before me. It was the death of all of them. I'm the only one who lived past fifty and now I'm stuck with you khamers!... 

Teaching all your Tatehs and Zaydies who had cowsheads just like you! Waiting for Rebbe Schkop to retire so I might get a few years as town Rabbi and a decent pension pay for my thirteen kinder instead of the bupkes your parents give me, and then he lived to hundred and would issue rulings from his bed! ...Ach... 

Alright. May Rebbe Schkop's memory be a blessing... But then your parents, more naarishkeit! They get a new Rabbi! God forbid a Kharlap be a Rabbi for them for a few years before he plotzes into the ground too! Another generation of Kharlap rebbes passed over for a pischer straight from the Yeshiva barely older than you who doesn't know life from the lamed vav. Schmeggeges, all of you!

(pause full five seconds and catches his breath)

Alright, I'm sorry kinder, I didn't mean all that. You know I have love for you all, you kinder are my life, and I just need you to learn so you can be a light to the goyim. 

Sunday, March 27, 2022

Tales from the Old New Land - Podcast Play Version - Opening Monologue - Draft 1

 Rebbe Yaakov Charlap: (opening until explosion should be as dull as possible) 

And so today we get to Parashas Vayeshev... It's the story of Onan, Tamar, Yehudah, and Er. Tamar, the beautiful bride, that a series of husbands refuse to blemish by making her pregnant, so Onan and Er always spilled their seed on the ground during schtupzeit. (kid laughs) Don't laugh. So God punished Onan and Er by killing them. And make no mistake, when you spill your seed anywhere but your wives, that's evil and Hashem might decide to punish you for it. (more kids laugh)

Please don't laugh, this is important! The Torah teaches a valuable lesson here.... like it always does.... (kids calm down) 

You don't have very long till your married, you all know what spilling your seed is, you need to not do it until you're married and can make geschlect in your wives.

(a bunch of kids laugh) 

NIBZEH L'AZAZEL KHALERIYA! You numbskulls are no better than wild animals!...  Is Dreyfus going through all this so you mamzerim can dishonor his sacrifice?!

Kid says distant from microphone: But Rebbe Kharlap...

Zay shtil you naarisher schmucks!...

Alright. Put your hands on the table! Everybody put your hands on the table! 

(Hits kids hands with switch between most sentences)

Laughing at the Torah! Laughing at women! Generation to generation of light-mindedness and ingratitude to your mothers! While you're busy not learning Torah they're making sure you don't starve or freeze to death! One day all of your wives'll be sick of your disrespect to women and rebel against you, and then where'll the world be?

 You farshtunkener Jewish hillbillies! How did I, how did my family, end up teaching generations of schlubs like you?! Fifty years teaching this stupid Kheder, just like my Tateh and Zaydie and Elter Zaydie before me, stuck teaching all your Tatehs and Zaydies who were just as dumb as you, waiting for Rebbe Schkop to retire so I might get a few years as town Rabbi and a decent pension pay for my thirteen kinder, and then he lived to hundred and would issue rulings from his bed! ...May his memory be a blessing... And then your parents... They get a new Rabbi, God forbid a Kharlap be a Rabbi for them. Another generation of Kharlap rebbes passed over for a bright and shiny rabbi straight from the Yeshiva who doesn't know life from the lamed vav. Worthless people! All of you!

Kharlap used to mean something around here. Kharlap! Khet Resh Lamed Pay! Khiya-Rosh-L'Galut-b'Polin, Khiya-Head of the Exiles in Poland! How did the descendents of Khiya end up teaching a bunch of numbskulls like you in this town Hashem forgot about? 

This is why I raised my kinder to be mensches! All thirteen of them! None of you naarisher pischers come up to their ankles! Twenty-five years I lived with my wife, and while your parents all had worthless kids, every Friday night we do things, and nothing. She was the most beautiful girl in the shtetl, now she's a little meeskait from her worries but she's still the most beautiful woman in Bransk. Why? Because she's an eshes chayil, a woman of valor!

Eighteen years ago an angel came to me in a dream! I demanded a blessing from him and he told me I would have twelve sons, and I had to name them after the twelve tribes of Israel! And sure enough, five sets of twins and a triplet over five years! And ALL of them survive to their Bar Mitzvahs! And now, sixty years old, she's pregnant again! Who'd ever heard of it! She was blessed by god! I was blessed by god while the rest of your are cursed. My kinder are going to be the blessed of the earth while you're all cold in the ground from some war or political edict! 

I know this kind will be a boy, and he's already worth more than you all put together! Every one of mein sohns are worth more than all of you put together! They're the light of Judaism! They're the light of the world! You dont' follow their examples but they're the examples you all should be looking towards! 

(hard cut to scene 2) 

Wednesday, March 23, 2022

New Tale from the Old New Land: Memo To Col. Putin - First Third

Memo: 12/25/89: CONFIDENTIAL

To: Lt. Col. Vladimir V. Putin

From: Dr Aleksandr Jakubovitch Berman

This memo has five objectives:

1. Predicting the fall of the Soviet Union, its reasons, and the extremely unstable US hegemony which will follow. 

2. Predicting the retribution through extreme economic hardships, hyperinflation and personal humiliations to which the US will subject what will soon again be Russia in a hard transition to capitalism under the guise of humanitarian aid. 

3. Predicting and outlining the conditions of extreme instability of an American hegemonic empire. 

4. Outlining how to use ideological subversion to maximize Russia's retrenchment as a world power. 

......

The internet provides far greater means for connection, communication, and connection through miscommunication, and therefore greater means than ever for ideological subversion. Furthermore, both the right wing and left wing of the new era's ideological reorientations have no innoculation against ideas which used to be belong to the other side. Nationalism still has no experience of universal movements that find enormous common ground between people of different continents, and socialism still has no experience of viewing identities as particular, and therefore, upon both sides, the ideas of one side can be embraced to the other with the most revolutionary fervor because neither side has any experience of its trevails. 

Through the internet, we may disseminate old Marxist theories in a new adapted guise that sound like nationalism, but thereby create a new international, universalist nationalism that finds common cause between countries in the shared resentments of cosmopolitan progressive elites. Should the Soviet Union fall, this transnational movement must led by Russia. We could create a new nationalist mythology in the United States whose elemental whiteness is just barely implicit, and based upon Republican's loathing for all taxes and government regulation, and belief in states rights. In order to disguise its association with longing for the white pride which came with segregation and slavery, one could use the Boston Tea Party of 1773 as its principal ikon. 

Simultaneously, we must use the internet to disseminate old nationalist theories to create a new socialism in America based upon particulars of identity that used to be the basis of nationalism. But to create a new concept of socialism, it must take root in the United States of America, the transnational country which defeated both nationalism and socialism. And perhaps we could create a new American socialism based on old theories of nationalism - reinventing concepts of the workers paradise into a world of social justice, metamorphosing theories of class structure to a hierarchical structure of identity that gives preference to which demographics suffered most over the course of American history, thereby exploiting the resentments of the American marginalized.  

The imperative of class warfare would be metamorphosed into identity politics that would gradually introduce more revolutionary concepts into the American discourse year by year until this new nationalist social movement was receptive to arguments in favor of violent resistance. 

To instill the new right-wing nationalism, we can incorporate the 19th century media structure of new Marxian pamphlets written every week for the 21st century with a television network from which propagandists may transmit ideologically approved content 24 hours a day, with stories spun to seem more dramatic and provocative every week that gradually convince viewers that the world operates according to a conspiracy of affluent cosmopolitan liberals who mean to take everything from the rural lower middle class. 

Meanwhile, as the worldwide left-wing is no longer among the establishment, they will gravitate to the newest forms of communication. It is the view of this analyst that the internet's most effective means of communication will be through a vehicle still in its theoretical stage, referred to by developers and theorists as 'social media', hosting sites upon which people hold conversations  in public with both friends and enemies - as there is no physical reprecussion for such conversations, the chances for discourse to grow rancorous are nearly infinite. Many further objections have been made to the concept of social media, because citizens can easily be convinced to publicly declare their most private information in public, but it's precisely this feature which could be used to our advantage. Perhaps there would no longer be need for a KGB in such an era, because through falsely created identities created by our own soldiers and programmers, we can amplify any story we find destructive to the US's  self-belief."

Explain how Edward Said wrote Orientalism, which took the beliefs of Herder and Spengler in the inability of different nations to properly perceive the context of one another's ideas,.and how Said turned that bulwark of German nationalism into the powerful vision identitarian Socialism yet has. But Herder did not count upon that the great strength of American liberal Democrats, largely comprised by demographics as the children of once oppressed and marginalized, is their ability to assimilate ever new contributions and worldviews from an ever wider array of people. So therefore charges of cultural colonialism would flummox any further liberal attempt to uplift the marginalized through assimilation, and thereby stymy any further liberal efficacy to adapt the world to its worldview.  Perhaps we can supervise a series of millions of internet postings which people charging that any attempt to utilize the work of another culture is a colonization of that culture - though perhaps one could use a subtler word to hide our motive like 'appropriation.'

Monday, March 21, 2022

Kirill Peternko and the Mountain of Musical Performance - Vastly Expanded From Initial Post

 

I don't know how I'm surprised. All artists eventually disappoint you - relatively speaking, but very time I buy a new week-long ticket to the Berlin Philharmonic's digital concert hall, I find myself a little less in awe of Kirill Petrenko. In some ways, I'm more in awe than ever, but he's almost too extraordinary for his own good. Everything moves like light speed and quicksilver, more nuances per second than virtually anyone in the history of the profession. And yet to what purpose?

What is music for? Music is not a quantifiable process, and just because you hear certain details articulated with precision does not make great music. And if a conductor exerts extraordinary control over the music, is he then repressing the chance for the performance to grow into a more human experience? If you view music as a schematic process, or architectonic, or a deductive process, that's perfectly acceptable, but you shouldn't expect that music makes you feel any more gratitude to be alive than a tchochkeh gifted by a friend you don't like. But if you view music the way a gardener might a plant, the music can take on the miracle of life, and a performance allows the music to grow into your inner life of its own accord in ways that contravene a score's blueprint. 

Now, that does not mean a performer should impose their own conception on top of the score's, it does, though, mean that the performer should 'follow the music' in whatever manner it develops. A performer must know the score intimately, the score is order, but a performance is chaos - music is literally the aural process of making order from the chaos that is our auditory process. So therefore, if the performer's momentary instinct contravenes the score, they have to follow the instinct. 

What creates great music is the tension between the score and the performance. A performer who slavishly follows the score finds no music within it, but a performer who willfully distorts the score has no score to interpret. What creates great music is the coming together in a special space; not a space just to coordinate notes, but a community of performers and listeners who express things to  each other as in a conversation. Like any living process, things can get both repressive and chaotic, but such is life, and if there isn't a certain amount of the living process where questionable decisions aren't allowed , it's either dead or a robot, but it's not alive. 

Make no mistake, Petrenko's no robot, nevertheless, there is still something about Petrenko that feels like a perfect conducting machine - one might say the same thing of Igor Levit's pianism (they even look like they could be brothers). Both of them have enormous vitality, intensity, focus in their musicmaking. Both of them feel like looking at a musical x-ray, and listening to them both can be a  profound, revelatory experience. But does the enlightenment they provide really result in a changed life? When I heard certain conductors live: Dohnanyi, Blomstedt, Jansons, I felt as though the curvature of my life itself was changed. I emerged feeling as though life was more bearable, durable, that music itself was there so that our souls could be purged and pacified. Petrenko and Levit elicit so much detail as to be an awesome experience of enlightenment, like looking into the Hubble Telescope. But when I emerged from Dohnanyi or Brendel, I felt as though I knew what it was like to live in outer space. 

The story of no artist is written until the end of their career, and there are already all sorts of great performances with the Berliners: not least Beethoven 9 and 7, Shostakovich 9 and 10, Tchaikovsky 5 and 6, Dvorak 5, and of course, all that Suk which is as great a service to music as Mackerras performed to Janacek... but when I hear the way Petrenko performs the works that matter the most to me: when I hear how he drives Brahms and Schubert mercilessly, when I hear the absence of tragedy in Shostakovich 8, when I hear blandness in Mozart's Gran Partita, I begin to wonder if a bit of heart and spirit is missing amid all that nuance and hard work, and I find myself missing Simon Rattle, who never tried to nail every nuance, but always let the music breathe and flow.

Rattle always got a bum reputation because he flew so high, but anybody who doesn't get Rattle has to re-evaluate their priorities, because they're missing out. The execution can be dirty, the interpretive decisions occasionally questionable, and sometimes, he can be just boring. But it is astounding how much humanity his performances can have. His performances are organic, they bleed color and breathe in and out with the flow of the work's harmonic tensions, and if he really gets the piece, he is as exciting as any musician on earth. Though lacking Lenny's genius, he is the closest thing Bernstein has to an heir. He has Bernstein's open-hearted communication, his spirit of embracing the audience, his omnivorousness that embraces every style, every expressive mood, every composer, every new idea, but he can also be self-effacing, and has an ability to 'downsize' and be intimate that Lenny's larger-than-life spirit lacked. 

Rattle is the 'liberal' to Petrenko's 'conservative.' Rattle's is an open process that allows for enormous mistakes, but he also allows for enormous rewards. He is clearly creating his interpretations in the moment, and the spontaneity allows for the most gorgeous surprises that stun even the musicians, and through that process shines through a glow of discovery, or a flow of an adventure. Petrenko's is a closed process, air to Rattle's water. Every note is checked, double checked, triple checked, for meanings he has clearly studied and worked over for years, and never allows for surprises in performance. The technical and intellectual process involved in Petrenko's approach is biblically awesome, but it does not feel of this world, and there's a level of humanity it lacks.  

But the Berlin Philharmonic was never an orchestra of this world, it was always an instrument meant to cause awe, not move to tears. There was no reason for Rattle to go to Berlin except the ego trip of landing the world's biggest appointment. Rattle is a towering artist, but he does not have the sheer gift of either a Petrenko or a Karajan, and he belongs in a place like London or Boston, that can appreciate him properly for his huge but occasionally flawed humanity and talent. The other day I compared Petrenko's Brahms 2 to Rattle's, and there was no comparison at all. Rattle, though not a Brahmsian for all time, was by so many miles the better performance, and then I listened to Semyon Bychkov, who is a Brahmsian for all time (and Petrenko's teacher), and oh my god....

Artists disappoint you, that's as much the nature of artists as athletes and lovers. There's no such thing as an artist you can look to for constant enlightment. You listen to them as part of their journey and yours. You rejoice in their successes and feel betrayed by their failures. If you feel constantly satisfied by an artist, you're probably trying to will yourself to hear what the artist hears. I love Mariss Jansons's musicmaking as I have no conductor I've ever heard live, especially in all kinds of Austro-Germans nobody thinks of him for.... but Jansons was a terrible Mahler conductor and I don't even care for him in the Richard Strauss recordings so many others love. The more I hear Semyon Bychkov,  long before he lead the musical pack in condemning Putin, the more I came to think that Bychkov has that Jansons-like generosity of heart married to musical skill and sense. Like Blomstedt or Dohnanyi, the rewards are delayed, and even if it takes a while, you eventually realize musicians like them reveal 'the world behind the world' and after it's done, you live your life differently. My reaction to artists like Bychkov is deeper than mere tears, it's days and days worth of mental peace. And yet I too find Bychkov a bad Mahler conductor - wooden and bombastic. 

Nobody in your life delivers what you need from them all the time. The only question is, who delivers it essentially? 

I've come up with a kind of 'mountain of musical performance' that I use as a metric for how meaningful a musical experience I've had. Please do not take this seriously in any sense, I understand that it's metaphysical bullshit, but it works for me and I'd encourage you to come up with your own. 

As my 'expertise', so to speak, is firstly conductors, then pianists, then violinists, this will only apply there. I don't have the depth of experience with singers to know how consistent are their rewards. And while there are only so many times I can listen to violin music before thinking to myself how paltry are the offerings compared to the piano, violin was in many ways 'my world.' On the other hand, however much I played chamber music as a kid, it's still something I'm slowly assimilating to the point that I feel I can offer meaningful comment. I don't think I'm there yet. 

Furthermore, please also mind that this 'mountain' only applies to questions of musical experiences that are already excellent. Mediocre music is mediocre music, and there's nothing to be done about mediocrity except to accept that the world will always have much more of that within it than excellence. 

There are clearly levels I'm missing. I don't know where to put artists who combine passion with formal severity in a way that creates an experience of that is both self-effacing and of the utmost emotional extremity, so I don't quite know where to categorize artists I greatly esteem like Emil Gilels, Jascha Horenstein, Gianandrea Noseda, Kyung-Wha Chung, or even Isaac Stern. 

So at the bottom of this mountain is 'merely' excellence. Excellence is its own reward, and there are plenty of artists gifted enough to provide that excellence in which you find no flaw. Excellence is always a staggering achievement which takes enormously hard work. When I've heard Riccardo Chailly conduct, when I hear piano played by Pollini or Julia Fischer on the violin, I am in awe of what they do, I'm astounded by their technique, their intelligence, and their energy. I cannot even imagine the decades of study it takes to build their musicianship to its fullest capacity. And many times, my brain is fed by their insights and I find things in the pieces I'd never heard before. But I am never moved, and if it's on a stereo (as usually), I feel a deathly chill that often motivates me to turn it off. 

As you begin to climb it, you get to 'delight,' and there's a special place in your heart for every one of these musicians. Even if you're not sure the artists aim for anything deeper than fun, you really do feel joy in their music. Among conductors, the obvious exemplar is Thomas Beecham, among pianists perhaps Ignaz Friedman, and among violinists, perhaps it's, dare I say, Maxim Vengerov. You could also count among this kind of artist Louis Lortie or Renauld Capucon. They're not deep, their performances are neither meaningful nor easily identifiable, they just play exuberantly with great personality, and almost inevitably give a joyful experience. 

And then you get to the level of 'magic moments,' provided by those musicians who, however inconsistent, always provide those magic moments when the music is never short of transcendent. Whenever I woudl hear Christoph Eschenbach conduct the National Symphony, I came to think that however unrehearsed or pompous an interpretation is otherwise, there are always moments - usually in the slow passages - that belong to the stars. And to be honest, that's also how I feel about (pauses for dramatic effect...) Daniel Barenboim.... Unless you think thick textured soup is a style, their styles are not even particularly recognizable, and they're not nearly as deep as their acolytes think they are (to say nothing of themselves...), but they almost inevitably provide moments, flashes, that make us wonder if the genius everybody alleges is really there. This is also, after more years and a number of mediocre live experiences, how I now feel about Michael Tilson Thomas. 

Then you get to 'enormity', the gigantic personalities who cannot help but be themselves. This is Furtwangler, this is Gould, this is Menuhin, Richter, Horowitz, Scherchen, Gieseking, Cziffra, Sokolov. the artists that; however enormous their insights and inspiration, are so larger than life that capture the composer on their own terms is nearly impossible. When you hear the aforementioned, you cannot help hearing the artist rather than the composer. They are, obviously, capable of the most titanic performances, but hearing their intensity can also feel like a terrible violation of your well-being. Spend too much time in their company and you could be driven mad. 

Past there is a level of 'education:' The instructional artists, whose every bar seems to be a running commentary on the piece. When you hear them, you can't help but understand better what the music is supposed to mean, even if you disagree completely with their conclusions. This is Bernstein, this is Arrau, this is Cortot, this is Edwin Fischer, this is Gidon Kremer.  and though cut off before his old master years, Zoltan Koscis was exactly this sort of pianist. Manfred Honeck is a particularly magnificent example of this sort of artist among today's conductors, and Adam Fischer is perhaps an extreme example of it. Ton Koopman is a particular example of this among period instrument keyboardists and conductors. However distracting or invasive, the new insights are almost constant in every bar of music, and it's nearly impossible to come away without thinking you've had a meaningful experience. 

And then, perhaps as the air gets a little thinner, there's 'enlightenment.' Not in the sense of some Buddhist zen thing (though maybe we'll get to that), but in the sense that by hearing them, you feel as though you can get a kind of absolute understanding of what this music is about (though of course that's an illusion). Though they're capable of so much more, this is Kirill Petrenko, this is Igor Levit. Before them it was Carlos Kleiber and Claudio Abbado, it was Eduard van Beinum, Igor Markevitch, Karel Ancerl,  Wolfgang Sawallisch, Michael Gielen, Bernard Haitink. It was the inhumanly awesome violin playing of Tossy Spivakovsky. It was Josef Hofmann, it was Robert Casadesus, Friedrich Gulda, Wilhelm Backhaus, Aldo Ciccolini. It's Paul McCreesh's revalatory but slightly pedantic performances of early music. You are almost a passive listener in an awesome experience, demanded at every moment to perceive what you're hearing at a level deeper than how your ear receives the content. Listening to them gives you an intellectual apprehension of exactly what the piece is - not in phrase-by-phrase, as more instructional artists do, but the work entire. 

And then, maybe there's a place where the air gets more breathable again, and you get finally to 'human connection', where the artists share with you all their deeply warm humanity in a place where you can feel as appreciated as though in a hug from your grandmother. I confess, I think there's an important level or two past here, but I can't help most of these being my favorites. Of course, this is the sociable humanity of Artur Rubinstein, but it's also the vivacity of Barbirolli, the luminous gemutlichkeit of Jochum, it's the enthusiasm of Koussevitzky and the wit of Monteux. It's the romanticism + irony of Ferenc Fricsay and the ironic classicism of Hans Schmidt-Isserstedt, it's the joy of Solomon, it's the bullseye characterization of Ivan Moravec, the immaculate suavity of Shura Cherkassky and the infinite subtlety of Rudolf Firkusny, the incredible mid-piece improvisations of Igor Kipnis, it's Bronislaw Huberman's mixture of gymnasium lecture and Yiddish street patois, and it's Ivry Gitlis's rolls in the gypsy mud. It's Benno Moisewitsch's journey through a perfume factory and Dmitri Mitropoulos's manic drama. It's Peter Maag subtle mayhem and Paul Kletzki's Yiddish-accented Furtwangler-keit. It's Klaus Tennstedt's desperate cry and Charles Munch's irresistible joie de vivre. It's the giant ursine tone of David Oistrakh's violin, the deceptively elegant incandescence of Zino Francescatti's. The intellectual restlessness of Thomas Zehetmair to the generous friendliness of Gil Shaham (who went vastly up in my estimation after I saw his approach in person as a now fully mature artist). Among today's conductors it's the non-stop experiments throughout the repertoire of Simon Rattle and Markus Stenz, and the non-stop experiments in traditional repertoire of Ivan Fischer and the non-stop song and dance entertainment of David Zinman. It's Marc-Andre Hamelin's non-stop piano adventures and Rachel Barton Pine's escapades through the violin's thousands of uses. It's Andrew Manze's period fun and Thomas Fey's period craziness. It's even Artur Schnabel and Nikolaus Harnoncourt, who both have so much in common with the educators, but are such loving educators that they seem to take you as their pupils through the entire universe. Everything from them is like a garrulous, friendly conversation, in which you are being invited with them to float on a boat down a gorgeous river while holding a beverage and talking about all things of the universe. They do not leave the work a space for itself but proactively guide the work with a rubato here, a dynamic swell there. Not so that you can appreciate merely them, but so that you can appreciate the work as they show it to you. When you listen to them, music flows, it makes you feel freedom and love. 

But it strikes me that there may be an even higher peak than freedom and love. Maybe that's the peak of the mountain and my priorities are temporarily misplaced, but I think there's a 'spiritual' level even past human connection. With Solomon and Huberman, you talk all the things of this universe, but with Kempff and Szigeti, you feel connected to all things of this universe. A spiritual connection, that by listening to it, you feel connected to a much larger space within the universe than mere humans. In their hands, the trivialities cease and you begin to feel as though you can live through your days at peace. For me, that's the great German conductors like Erich Kleiber and Bruno Walter and Otto Klemperer and Gunter Wand, it's Giulini in choral music, and it's Harnoncourt in Bach (which I've fallen back in love with). It's the combination of warmth and severity you get from 'greatest generation' maestri: Blomstedt, Skrowaczewski, Masur, Davis, Inbal, Tate, Cantelli, GR and RFDB. That combination of warmth and severity is also what you get from a violinist like Schlomo Mintz - the world's warmest tone, the world's most austere adherence to form; and while I was tempted to put Itzhak Perlman way down at the merely joyful artists, the Jew in me can't stop thinking that there is something much higher about Perlman's approach than it often seems. His sweetness is not diabetes, it is genuinely thought through and a means to lift the heart. It's the inexorable tread of Rudolf Serkin, it's the delicate gentleness of Dinu Lipatti. It's Stephen Kovacevich and Vladimir Ashkenazy and Krystian Zimerman. It's the giant organic vibrations in the harpsichord of Wanda Landowska, the lute-like strum of George Malcolm's, the lacerations of suffering from Zuzana Ruzickova and the warm severity of Rosalyn Tureck. It's also, frankly, the pagan sensuality of Janine Jansen and Leila Josefowicz (oy). Artists like all these are peaceful, calming experiences, that give you something much deeper than simply moving your heart or stimulating your brain. They reveal a luminous 'world beyond the world', and go straight to the soul. Every note is treated like a human being and given space to be heard. 

And finally, there's the place beyond infinity, that simply lets you know the human place in the universe. A place of ultimate musical truth. It's the celestial sphere where music has miraculous healing powers, but quite simply: Rafael Kubelik, Fritz Busch, , Mariss Jansons, Christoph von Dohnanyi, William Steinberg, Semyon Bychkov, Ferenc Fricsay (in opera), Wilhelm Kempff, Alfred Brendel, Andras Schiff, and Leon Fleisher after his dystonia. Among contemporary pianists, I believe Paul Lewis belongs here as well. And among baroque keyboardists, probably only Gustav Leonhardt. 

Among, violinists, it's harder to talk about, because I began on the violin, and there is too much emotion bound up in the instrument for me. There are a lot of violinists that mean a lot to me, and violinists go up and down in my estimation all the time. Perhaps Fritz Kreisler belongs here, even with all his schmaltz. Perhaps Joseph Szigeti, with all his severity. Perhaps Arthur Grumiaux, with all his predictability. Perhaps Nathan Milstein, with all his efficiency. But at the moment, there are only two that I know belong here in my bones: one is Josef Suk, who never met a work noble enough that he couldn't dignify it more. The other is Georges Enescu, whom even after his intonation went, merely had to put the bow to the string. 

Beyond that is a place not even music can reach.