Saturday, December 30, 2023

A quick listening guide to Leonard Bernstein



We won't get into anything that wasn't his compositions.

A+:
West Side Story (obviously. Look, it's probably the greatest theater work this country ever produced. Your life is poorer without knowing it. The best way to know it is to find the Spielberg movie and watch it on the biggest screen you can find. In the meantime, listen to the original Broadway soundtrack, which has still never been bettered.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-oyVRuPRlY&list=PL2HvIoVJcahcqRssUsnv0g8lV3W-I2TfL&index=10

A:
Candide (WSS's companion piece. It doesn't work as a show. It's just one thing, after another, after another, but along with Porgy and Bess, it just might be the most amazing music ever composed for Broadway)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kovAiSbTyBI&list=OLAK5uy_l84_XoNl81Szssi1_CjfkTqPVENs6x1NQ&index=2&fbclid=IwAR0Rk1eAZIXeEBoLEALQyqz4JJRxe69UA0KUFWdUUVV668JCJlvnPIHq8AQ

On the Waterfront Suite: (Lenny's only movie score. It's one of the all-time movie scores, and here are twenty minutes of the most evocative music ever composed about New York) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ojnVIW3wRJo

Fancy Free: (Bernstein's ballet on the subject of three sailors with a day of shore leave in New York. This is the piece in 1944 when Lenny truly becomes Lenny, that brash, unmistakably New York voice that combines classical and jazz in a third stream fifteen years before third stream jazz was a genre.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G91xB1a2ftU&list=OLAK5uy_nITeKxfMVD1yTTkXKwFZ3piLWwTId5WLw

Symphonic Dances from West Side Story: (just the orchestral music - and a little bit more - that gives as good a sense of New York as anything in On the Waterfront) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J_NelA3ZW4g

A-

On The Town: (That incredible first show of his, based on Fancy Free. Another one of the most incredible shows put on, as a soundtrack the love songs are a little more insipid than onstage, maybe because it never got a great performance.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t062tjKmK_I&list=PLaEnMuxCkiA4h6JHoYJqRN2H1xQS4Yg7W&index=16

Jeremiah Symphony: (A biblical evocation of the prophet Jeremiah and his lamentations, inveighing against sin and in the middle, a depiction of the orgiastic sinners he so loathes - you may psychologize away, but written in 1942 and knowing the destruction that would soon make itself public, it's very difficult not to be deeply moved) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uic4qcyDmDQ

B+:

(Bernstein's 20 minute sacred piece that sets ancient Hebrew psalms as pure Broadway) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PnrZGTmMjYc

B:

Wonderful Town: It's almost pure fluff, but it's fun fluff) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNWpiNPK8tg&list=OLAK5uy_lIqAhr80hXDCsO-WBOrcEPIp_u3fJMFKc&index=11

B-:
The Age of Anxiety: (At this point, I think there's only one movement that matters in this symphony: the jazz movement. Oh my god I love this.)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ftPNojzZYHw&list=OLAK5uy_nZTOZ1rFILOj3JB2u2hcxygtufuCnAHZ4&index=18

C: Serenade - another work of Lenny in pretentious mode, a musical depiction of Plato's Symposium on the nature of love. It has a lot of exciting stuff, but let's get serious, this is not philosophy.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpROC4gsZhQ

D: Kaddish Symphony: (It's not good... but getting rid of Bernstein's own pretentious text helped enormously, and replacing it with the testimony of Holocaust Survivor Samuel Pisar -Anthony Blinken's stepfather - makes it come much closer to working. It's not a masterpiece, but at least with some moral weight you get closer to what he must have been aiming for.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zTAnmHPTKEk

F:

Mass: Oh god it sucks.

Thursday, December 28, 2023

Free Speech

Here's a preemptive f*** you to every single person who's ever taken a side in this particular Israel/Palestine debate.

Of course cancel culture exists, it obviously does, it always has, and there is no better evidence than the Israel debate of how both sides use it disingenuously as a political weapon and have for the better part of a hundred years.

The idea that the pro-Palestine side invokes free speech now after having suppressed speech on so many other issues from... to... I don't want to say them because it will get everybody mad and get me ever asymptotically closer to the complete cancellation I've courted for thirty years. The hypocrisy of the pro-Palestine left is so unbelievably outrageous. Your chickens have finally come home to roost and it could not come a moment too soon and one can only hope your behavior results in the same in... any other country in the world.

Meanwhile, the right and center who've complained about cancel culture for years are now doing everything they can to silence everybody who disagrees with them into non-persons. This is... this is... this is... everything you claim to hate, and even if the pro-Palestine side completely controls academia and just about every government in the world, your side literally controls a government that can countermand the will of the entire world. Anti-Israel resolutions can't even get through congress with 20 votes. What more could you possibly need in America? Every attempt to suppress it will just make the oppostion to you worse.

Who's right in this debate? Everybody is, and everybody is also deeply, deeply wrong.

It's understandable. In a war, everybody fights dirty, but for god's sakes, own what you're doing. You don't have righteousness on your side, you're just indulging in the same base slime everybody does who wants their side to win.

Wednesday, December 27, 2023

ET: Almanac

 It is on. The Rosenbergs are to die at last. Television networks interrupt programs with the announcement: "President Eisenhower and the Supreme Court of the United States of America have refused to spare the lives of atomic spies Julius and Ethel Rosenberg." At the Bernard Bach home in Toms River, New Jersey, a small ten-year-old boy is watching the baseball game between the New York Yankees and the Detoit Tigers on channel 11 when the announcement is made. The score is 0-0, but Yankee first baseman Joe Collins has just beat out a drag bunt in the bottom of the fourth. It is a sunny day and the boy is thinking about going out to play baseball with friends in the neighborhood. That's what Sonia Bach wants him to do. But he's fascinated by the television and can't pry himself away from it. The announcer says the executions are scheduled to take place tonight. He looks very intent and serious. The boy tries to see past him to the ballgame again, but the announcer won't go away. "My Mommy and Daddy," the boy whispers, feeling that someone or something is watching him. But he doesn't know what to add. A prayer? A seventh-inning stretch? At the ballgame, nobody seems to have noticed that the announcement has been made. Yankee outfielder Gene Woodling has come to the plate during the interruption, and he now watches a ball go by. There's something magical about TV, everything seems to happen at once on it, the near and far, the funny and sad, the real and the unreal. Tonight! Collins, taking a big lead off first base, is not thinking about this. He doesn't care. The boy hates Collins for his cheap hit. Just like the Yankees. His Mom and Dad like the Brooklyn Dodgers; the New York Yankees are Judge Kaufman's team. Judge Kaufman is rich and lives on Park Avenue and takes his sons to see them play. The boy feels that awful lump growing in his stomach again. His little brother is out on the front porch with Leo painting a homemade Father's Day card with watercolors. Father's Day is Sunday, a long time away. "That was their last chance," the boy tells himself, trying to picture this new finality in the same way he sees the Tiger pitcher stretch, study Collins at first, then whip the ball toward the plate: ball two! Are the other guys in the neighborhood watching the game, did they hear the announcement? His mom and dad have told him it's not manly to be afraid, but he is afraid, he can't help it. He feels like there are two of himself loose in this world, one who likes to play baseball with friends and come home to Mom and Dad and sometimes push his little brother around, and another one on television and in the newspapers who is threatening to eat the other one up. Both of them, the one eating and the one getting eaten, are frightened, because they both believe the world is not crazy, how could it be? and yet why is it doing these maniac things? why is it killing his Mom and Dad like this, and why is everybody so excited about it, and what is it they want with him, a plain ten-year-old boy who's still learning his fractions and doesn't even know how to fix a television or throw a curve ball yet. "Why don't you go and play catch with Steve?" says Sonia gently. She is being too nice to him. Like everybody else of late. Even Mr. Bloch. Sometimes he feels like shouting at them: damn you all! Woodling slams a one-strike, two-balls pitch clean out of the ballpark, and the Yankees lead, 2-0. The television camera shows people cheering and waving and having a terrific time. If people really loved one another, he wonders, would the world be like this? His poor Mom! What is she thinking? How does it feel? What is love in a world where people behave like this as if it were normal. Woodling circles the bases. His little brother comes in, wearing his Brooklyn Dodgers T-shirt all smeared with paint, and asks Sonia for a glass of milk. "That's it. That's it," the boy says, "Good-bye." "Good-bye." Nobody's listening. 

His folks lawyer Manny Bloch is having the same experience: he and his defense team are flinging themselves frenetically at any judge they can find at home or in chambers, but they all seem to have vanished or gone deaf. A stone wall. Manny fires off a telegram to President Eisenhower, raising the Hugo Black point that the case has not been reviewed by the Supreme Court, but this wire is short-circuited by Special Counsel Bernie Shanley and "transmitted to the Justice Department": Eisenhower never sees it, Bloch, who has fallen unprofessionally in love with the entire family, is beginning to lose his forensic cool and is having flashes of self-destructive temper, as the doors slam shut in his face. He and others plead for a stay of eleven-p.m. executions tonight because of the Jewish Sabbath which begins at sundown. Kaufman, playing it close to the chest, says he has already spoken with Attorney General Brownell about that: the executions will not be carried out during the Sabbath. The lawyers take this to mean a delay is in the offing, past the weekend at least, and relax a moment: at Justice, they exchange knowing winks. 

The Rosenbergs themselves, locked away in the stillness of Sing Sing Death House, are remote from all this noisy maneuvering, but they are not unaware of it. One thing they know: they are not alone in this world. Julius even clings to the mad hope that justice will be done, that they will be vindicated, these walls will come crashing down, and they will ride out of here on the shoulders of their friends, the people, but Ethel, though never more strong and serene, shares her son's mood of grim resignation: that's it, good-bye, good-bye. She sits with Julie, separated from him by a wire-mesh screen, composing a farewell letter to the two boys. What she wants above all is to save them from cynicism and despair, so she speaks of the fellowship of grief and struggle and the price that must be paid to create a life on earth worth living. Julie, watching her, nods in agreement, awed by her radiant tranquility . . . 

. . . Your Daddy who is with me in the last momentous hours, sends his heart and all the love that is in it for his dearest boys. Always remember that we were innocent and could not wrong our conscience. We press you close and kiss you with all our strength.

Lovingly,

Daddy Julie and Mommy Ethel

Julius's mother, Sophie Rosenberg, turns up meanwhile at the gates of the White House asking to see the President, but they don't even let her get close--her emotional behavior is notorious, and besides, she's not in good health, and people near the end are capable of anything--so she has to do her scene in the streets. Much is happening out there. Demonstrations are building up in Washington, New York, around the world. Riots are expected and police everywhere are put on special alert. Bloch blames Judge Kaufman for stirring up all this trouble through his merciless intransigence: "Tens upon tens of millions of people in this country, in Europe, in Asia, know about this case!" The Boy Judge is not taken in: "I have been frankly hounded, pounded by vilification and by pressurists--I think it is not a mere accident that people have been aroused in these countries. I think it has been by design!" On a crepe-paper banner strung out above the Republic Chop Suey eatery in Times Square, Senator Frank Brandigee's immortal rejoinder to Woody Wilson: 

I AM NOT GOING TO BE BUNCOED BY ANY OLEAGENOUS LINGO 

                   ABOUT "HUMANITY" OR "MEN EVERYWHERE" 

 

 

 

 

Robert Coover: The Public Burning - Beginning of Chapter 16, will try to copy the whole chapter later. 

Tuesday, December 26, 2023

At best..

Being caught in the middle is a tough place no matter where you are, but when the issues are existential, nobody wants to concede you might be right because that means that their very strong feelings are wrong. This is why I generally insist on not talking about Israel in person anymore except a few close friends and my immediate family with whom I can't avoid the topic. Literally the entire world wants you to tell them what you think privately, and it's always just a smokescreen for them to tell you why you're wrong. What's the point of enduring all this public online heat if we have to endure it person-to-person too?

I have never been completely sanguine on this war, and until the far-right threat is gone from the Israeli government, I never will be. Jews do not endure this ever-present specter of death only to become the death we fear, but I will never apologize for Jews doing what they have to to survive, so long as it's essential for its survival. Well off socialists will never understand what it means to live in a dangerous neighborhood, and neighborhoods don't get more dangerous than Israel's. Doing nothing can get you killed. Doing the wrong thing can get you killed too.

But with the news that Israel has killed a top Iranian official in Syria, my willingness to spill blood for this fight gets thinner until Netanyahu goes. There is no point of killing people except if lives are ultimately saved, and this ends more lives than it saves.

I could be wrong, but I don't think Israel meant to kill this guy. I don't think it was a targeted assassination. I think he simply happened to be at a Syrian base from where Israeli forces were worried weapons of mass destruction could be deployed, and the whole reason he was there was to inspect the base for its fitness to deploy exactly such weapons.


They did not know a high Iranian official would be on the premises, and as usual these days, some high ups in Israel fucked up. This time, it would not surprise me if the Netanyahu administration and the military pretended their incompetence was deliberate.


But this is exactly the excuse Hezbollah needs to saturate the north of Israel with missiles, any of which have a much better chance of having WMD's attached than any missile coming from Gaza. Will they? Probably not, not yet at least, but the clock is ticking, and the whole world is getting closer to a point of no return.

What is the point in supporting a war when you can't get rid of leaders who are, at best, willfully incompetent?

Israeli Christmas

It may be a Jewish state but Christmas in Jerusalem is an extraordinary thing. Thousands of pilgrims around the Old City flooding churches of every denomination and language that are hundreds of years old, sometimes thousands. It is one of the great events of the Israeli year, and life without it feels empty. I'd imagine a lot of it is still going on in Jerusalem even if at nothing like that scale, but Christmas without pilgrims would be unthinkable in Bethlehem and Nazareth, and one has to assume there is no such pilgrimage there presently. Just emptiness and sadness in places where thousands experience the most profound joy every year.

War depopulates, not just life but all the things which make life worth living.

I wish every Notzri out there a Merry Christmas. May you get your time in Jerusalem back, and may we all figure out a way to share this place while letting all our best traditions thrive. Life itself depends on it.
All rea

Sunday, December 24, 2023

I wish I hadn't defriended so many anti-Israel people

I could totally use their posts to refute them now.  

Saturday, December 23, 2023

So Long as Bibi Stays...

 Today Iran threatened to cut off the Mediterranean Sea at the Strait of Gibralter. I don't know how Iran would get over there and they could be stopped in a hundred different ways for a hundred different reasons, but the fundamental fact of Bibi's presence remains the same regardless:

Everyone is in danger. Not just Gaza, not just Israel, the world. So long as Bibi stays, we have an actor in place willing to risk a world war rather than give up power, even an actor in place willing to use a world war to his advantage.
Until the deaths get close to 100,000, I don't pay much attention to the outrages of world conflicts. 20,000, if that's the real number, is still below average for the median worldwide crisis. The fact that it's happened in 2 1/2 months, that's pretty remarkable, but so long as the crisis soon moves into the next phase, it would be just another world crisis, without much to remark on except for the incredible amount of attention it engenders while crises that get next to none rage far more lethally.
But so long as Bibi is in power, this crisis will not end, and if it goes on for a year with the same policy, the death toll, if Gaza's Health Ministry tells the whole truth (doubtful), may go to 90,000. THAT is remarkable, and that is an infamy Israel would do extraordinarily well to avoid.
I may be the only person in the world who sees it, but Bibi has arched for a dictator's unlimited power his whole time in office, and is looking for any way to get it. Hamas handed him a golden ticket.
When Hamas would like to kill a million Jews or many more, we have no choice but to support this would be dictator as we tacitly do dozens of others across the world. This is simply a fact of foreign policy everywhere, but that does not change that Israel is in the gravest peril of becoming the dictatorship the world suspects they already were. Should Israel get there, does Israel become the threat to world peace the world pretends Israel has always been?

Where then must we lend our support?

What Would I Do in Israel?

 The truth is that I have no desire to go back. I have a few friends and family worth seeing, but however much at 24 I romanticized being a journalist in the middle of an Israeli war, there's very little about experiencing a war that's worthwhile unless you get to pose like Camus for a black-and-white photo with sunglasses and a cigarette in your mouth. For the hoi polloi, there's just the general hell of enduring it, and however much it must be endured in Israel, one can only imagine what it means to endure it in Gaza, either as a Palestinian or an Israeli soldier.

The only reason to go back would be to write about it, and for whom would I be writing? The few friends who read me here? Does anybody actually read me here?

No, the real reason to go back would be for my continued grandiose delusion of Jewish history novels, because I want to experience what Jews act like under siege. I would imagine there are incredible situations: dramatic, tragic, comic, heroic situations, situations of cowardice, irony, love and hate so far past anything I could imagine or read about that to miss out on great material is the biggest regret for a mediocre artist looking to become good at what he does.

I have no desire to have the Israel experience again, but history is being made right now, and I'm missing it, almost 42 and with no overwhelmingly pressing responsibilities to keep me here.

There are probably dozens of Jewish ne'er do wells with exactly the same thought right now. It's a pseudo-intellectual's 'get rich quick' scheme: go to Israel, write about what you see, and somehow people will pay attention that never paid attention before.

But my real desire is not to write about this war, it's to write about war generally. It's to write about the long Jewish history of enduring sieges and mounting them, the long history of being victims and perpetrators, the long history of moral infamies and ambiguities that follow us everywhere we go, and the long history that whatever hell we pay to other peoples will be visited upon us seventy-seven fold.

That's why I want to go to Israel.

...I probably won't.


Thursday, December 21, 2023

Books that will help: a start

 I don't do many 'book reviews' here. It's not because I don't read. I read at least fifty pages a day, sometimes well over a hundred. I read four hundred books every year, I finish a dozen. The 50-100 pages a day is rarely of the same book and my record of finishing all the books I start is pretty abysmal. Like every intellectual striver ruined by the internet, I'm much better with magazine-length essays and essay collections than with full-length books. Books can't be consumed in one sitting, they have to be remembered from day to day, and what interests you from one day has to be the same as what interests you the next. I've read many books with chapters out of order, I've read many books skipping the sections that bore me, I've read many books having come back at the place I put down twenty years ago.

I'm a reader, but I'm a terrible reader, and someone without that work ethic for reading shouldn't trust themself to remember everything they need to remember to talk about books properly.

So here are the books that I think will be of value to people, divided into the books I've, more or less, read, and the books I've, less or more, haven't read.

...come to think of it I don't have the nerve to do it yet

Tuesday, December 19, 2023

This is so not what I'm supposed to be doing

 If nothing else, when this is over, I hope I've earned a couple readers for whatever fiction I write.

Like my music, the majority of it is dense, it's dark, it's hard to assimilate, I'm not sure I'd look forward to reading a lot of it if I didn't write it, but it's really only dense if you are accustomed to something user friendly. I think the things I can say in fiction are much more interesting things than anything I can say in essay form. Essays inevitably end up becoming polemics of what you believe and only you, but in fiction, you can get a whole community of beliefs, in dialogue with each other, creating the workings of what a whole community thinks, a whole society, whole eras and peoples.
It's not that what I have to say is important, though sometimes I've deluded myself as a way of keeping morale up, but the things I have to say are only able to be said the way I write it. I was not born with the gene to make myself accessible, I wish I was. Delete that, I think they are important to say, but I think it's important that someone say them, not me.
For better or worse, I've come to realize that Jewish history is my life, I'm boxed in by it and have never been able to escape it, so I've had a very dense epic of Jewish history in my head for the better part of fifteen years that I only made a workable start on in the last two.
Shortly before 'this' all started, I was exhausted by it. If I couldn't convince the editor I paid that this was the way it had to be written, how could I convince anyone to publish it, let alone read it or like it? But it stays in me, insisting on itself, aching to get out, if only I have the nerve to persist through all the doubts.
------------------------------------------------------------------------

More later probably...
All reac

Sunday, December 17, 2023

When Left Goes Right

 "...but right now we're gonna party like there's no tomorrow, cuz there's no feelin' in the world half as good as winnin', but the sun will come up, and the knives will come out, and all these smilin' faces will be watchin' me, watin' for that one first moment o' weakness, and then they will gut me like a deer.'

It's from 'All the Way', this is the second half one of my favorite speeches in any movie or play, a work about LBJ (Lyndon Johnson) and the steep price of politics in the raw.
It's not just how politics interacts, it's how humans interact. What we call 'cancel culture' doesn't just exist, it began before the internet, it began when humans began existing, it never began, it was always there as a technique by which societies enforced their norms. Usually they were bad norms enforced in bad conscience, a way of seeing in other people those ugly notions about humanity we repressed in ourselves, and if you've never seen the problem with it, you've never been cancelled. But anybody who lived even a few months of their life as a non-person recognizes the phenomenon, even if it was friends turning on you in high school to avoid getting cancelled themselves.
I lived this sort of cancellation multiple times in a cult-like high school where the possibility of cancellation was present in every interaction, and so did many I knew. Occasionally I was one of the cancellers: friends were practically ordered to turn on each other by the administration and faculty. I'm even sure that many students who didn't endure cancellation lived in fear of the place's heavy, blunt apparatus.
I moved nearly as far left as one could move when I was there, seeing in that place human's full capacity for authoritarianism, but I had the bad luck of starting college in Washington right as 9/11 happened. It moved me to the center prematurely, and then I began the slow crawl back to some kind of left. I'm no leftist today, but I'm a 'left conservative.'
It's not because I think the 'right' and Trumpers are trustworthy that I occasionally sympathize with them, it's precisely because however much I fear the woke world, I fear the Trump world more.
You may think you understand how much the right resents you. You don't. It's so much worse. I won't get into the details, but they think we have destroyed this country, that all of us not on their side represent an existential threat to them and everything they hold dear. They don't see us as the enemy worthy of death, but they do see us as the enemy's helpers, and therefore a threat worthy of imprisonment. People on the left want to avoid and shun those who disagree with them, people on the right want to end and break those they disagree with.
Even in an era that does not put ill on so many people, this shunning is one of life's many seasons; but in an era when every interaction is politicized, interactions become far more dangerous.
It's the nature of partisan extremes to have a kind of borderline personality disorder, a schism in the mass psyches by which the same people who 'love bomb' you to win you over are the people who mistrust you once you're welcomed in. The very fact that you once believed otherwise from what they did means they will look for signs of unpleasantness, dissent, even misbehavior, because keeping the commitment of the values of the group is more important than individual relationships.
We obviously live in fraught times when people behave irrationally, but the most irrational are not the far leftists or even the far rightists, it's the no less than millions who've recently moved left to right. It's not just the pundits and entertainers, it's the laymen who depend on them for what to think.
I'm not going to wade into the details of the irrationalities the left believes, it's much too controversial for now and I don't want to alienate more people than I suspect I already have, but once you stipulate so many dogmas to be thought a decent human, it follows that more and more people will dissent, and once they disbelieve the orthodoxies of the left, all notions the left disbelieves come into question, including notions on which the left is very much correct.
At the end of this post I'm linking to an article which perfectly describes one of the great irrational phenomena of our times, and like the perfect progressive thinkpiece, ascribes it to a complex cocktail of reasons. Good on them for identifying the trend, but as for their diagnosis: bullshit.
Politics is not determined by the head, it's a phenomenon of heart and nerves: a visceral reaction to what most inspires you and most offends you. Conservatism, as Galbraith said, is the eternal search of a justification for selfishness. What moves our generation right is the fear of cancellation, pure and simple.
You'd think this is the moment when ostensible progressives understand how high the stakes are and circle their wagons all too happily, but quite the opposite's happened. The tighter the wagons circle, the more leftists leave the circle to go right with full knowledge of the current right might be anti-democracy. Why? Because they think the left is anti-democracy too. Why do they think that? Because of how they were treated themselves.
Most of them claim they're anti-Trump, but whom do they support? Well, 16% of polls claim they would vote for RFK Jr. RFK Jr. is known as the antivaxxer conspiracy theorist, but his insanity goes so far beyond what you might think it does, and so does his influence. Every month, his website with all his conspiracies gets 4.7 million unique visits! Again, I won' go into detail, there's just too much to write and it's too depressing: rather, go here to this Slate article for details of what he believes about COVID and vaccines, Anthony Fauci, Bill Gates, AIDS, and, of course, the Kennedy assasinations: https://slate.com/.../rfk-jr-conspiracy-theories-vaccines...
THIS is our center alternative. Not even traditional conservative Republicans like Lynn Cheney or Ben Sasse, but rather: 16% of the country would sooner vote for a man who promotes these conspiracies than a President with 36 years of a voting record in the Senate that bespeaks far too sensible moderation because he welcomed an unwelcoming left into his tent.
There is only one possible explanation for this, not political but personal: the fear of isolation from those dozens of friends who brook no disagreement, the fear of rejection, the fear of a life without love and support.
That fear is what provoked many people far left to begin with. A quote from this thinkpiece below, dealing with the 'horseshoe theory' that the two sides begin to resemble each other, doesn't quite describe what happens. "...a political spectrum bending to met at its extremes, doesn't describe this drift. It goes in one direction."
It doesn't go in one direction, it goes in both, but the ones who go right to left usually happen in high school. It's those kids who grew up in the Christian right, among jocks who beat them up and families who only read the Bible and only listen to worship music: these are the ones who end up rebelling in punk rock and metal, b-horror movies and science fiction, who make up the extremity of the left's bulwark. It's only when they get thirty years older that we get the opposite phenomenon of people moving right once they have teenagers of their own.
Why? I would think it would be obvious but I'm clearly the only one: it's just that hard to keep up with the impossible standards you set.
It's this far below the fold, where nobody is reading, that I'll put the impetus for this post, and the dynamics that made me realize just how deep this pathology goes.
...actually, I can't, I'm just not that brave. Maybe another time.

Friday, December 15, 2023

What Biden's Doing

This isn't going to be long.
It's time for Israel to scale back. We've made our point. Are we really now going to hunt Hamas by shooting our way through the DP camps? It's not about killing people, it's about deterring Hamas. According to some Israeli sources, they've killed as many as 7,000 Hamas fighters. if that's true and the killed number of 18-20,000 is accurate, that would mean just about everybody killed that isn't Hamas is a woman or child. That's both an astonishingly high rate of success, an astonishingly low collateral damage considering the circumstances. It's also, if it's true, an astonishingly brutal series of statistics - speaking to just how awful Hamas's tactics really are.
Back in 2006, Israel went into Lebanon as a way of deterring Hezbollah. The action was controversial in Israel for not pursuing it to the point of ending Hezbollah, and it was controversial to the world for having done it all. Hezbollah is still there, but Hezbollah has never kidnapped another Israeli and it never again launched a full rocket war. Even if Hezbollah resumes where Hamas left off, the Lebanese have not stood for or a repeat of 2006 for nearly two decades. For seventeen years it's been deterred.
We are now at the point that any further Hamas deterrence is redundant. If you want to get rid of Hamas, don't try to deplete them completely. Even if the figure of displacement is inaccurate, there's no way that less than half of Gaza has been displaced, and it very well may be much much closer to the 90% figure Hamas fed us in the media. When well over a million Gazans have been displaced., the point is made, and it's up to Gazans to draw the conclusions of where their leadership has lead them.
Part of the reason I 'left the left' twenty years ago is that the left never understood how foreign policy works. You can't just support the good guys. You have to wade into moral ambiguity if you want any influence on how potentially bad leaders conduct themselves. Coming out mostly on the Palestinian side, even were it justified, would only get more Palestinians killed because Israel would 'go it alone' and be completely unanswerable to any ally about human rights concerns. If the dead are actually 20,000 at this point, Israel without allies could have killed 40,000 more by now or even many more than that.
The only way to apply pressure on Israel was to ally with them. But now that the US has proven its support, it's time to apply heavy pressure to move to the phase of filling in the tunnels as quickly as possible, and then comes phase 3: withdrawal. It's delusional to expect that anybody can replace Hamas but the Gazans themselves, and Israel has to get ready to leave and let a people hold their government accountable. And even if Gazans don't (they won't...), the chances of Hamas employing this tactic again are unlikely at best. And if they start going after Jews like us abroad, maybe this will finally be what convinces NATO that something has to be done about Hamas rather than us put up with Europeans treating another 6 million Jews like non-persons. But any further carpet bombing or targeting in crowded areas will just bind the Palestinians to Hamas as they wait longer and longer to go home and fear their mortality.
This is the time to move into phase 2 where the tunnels are effectively filled and the booby traps diffused. I was wrong when I defended the tunnels years ago and said that the tunnels were largely for economic purposes, so was the world, and so, I believe, was Netanyahu, who probably based his intelligence decision to be less vigilant about Hamas because he received the same intelligence the New York Times did that Hamas was using the tunnels mostly to smuggle in food and economic materials rather than the weapons of war. So the tunnels have to be filled. This is the priority now, not further depletion of Hamas's ranks.
...but even if that's what we want, even if that's what Biden wants, that's not going to be what Israel does, is it?

Wednesday, December 13, 2023

The Hypocrisy Arms Race

 Again, I'm the wrong person to write this post. I'm much too cynical and only grow more as I age. Whether it's to point out the double standards in people's treatment of people of color, white people, or Jews, my perception of people crying for justice just gets sadder and sadder. Not lower, just sadder at how they don't realize that they're still more entrapped than they think they are.

Just ask yourselves a question, one that I've already posed: why is it that there is so much more outcry, in both the leftist world and the Islamic, for Palestine rather than Yemen where 300,000 are almost beyond doubt murdered by the Yemenite government (HEAVILY backed by the Saudis)? Just one of a half-dozen horrifying examples I could name.
The answer isn't quite antisemitism. It's a lot more complex than that, yet it isn't that complex. The answer is that, unlike in Yemen, it's being done by 'someone else.' In the hierarchy of privilege, Jews?..., when it counts we're seen as privileged, so we count as the untethered white oppressor. Rightly or wrongly,.
But the point is not Jews, Jews are just a straw man as we often are for the real problem. The problem is that to hold an Islamic country, even Saudi Arabia, to the kind of accountability to which we hold Israel is tantamount in many minds to admitting that not all people of color are victims of a white oppressor. Jews are seen as white, As I said yesterday, the majority of Jews in Israel--and the VAST majority of right wing Jews--are descended from other parts of the Middle East who in no sense even look white. But to put too much focus on Yemen or Ethiopia or South Sudan is viewed as an implication to non-white people of "Get your house in order!"
Jews? Well, historically, we haven't had nearly as many chances over history to be hypocrites, and every time we were we found the world ready to point out all our flaws and then some, but insofar as we have our hypocrisies, our hypocrisy is pretty breathtaking right now.
Just take the current 'cancel culture' debate of academia, this debate is just a distraction from issues that matter, and no side in it looks like anything but a cretin. I've gone through all this before, but the hypocrisy of both sides should take everybody's breath away.
Or for that matter, still more obviously, take the question of Israel being a democracy in a region of nothing but autocracy. So long as Netanyahu is still in power, this argument has frayed beyond repair. People can say all the want that Netanyahu will be gone soon, but until Netanyahu is gone, the argument is moot.
And for that matter, so many Jews complain about how Western liberals used to have Israel's back. Well, Israel turned its back on liberalism since 1977. In the 46 years since, Israel's been run by a right-wing Prime Minister for 37 of them. It used to be thought of as the near apex of worldwide social democracy, but has long since stripped its kibbutzim for nearly every dollar to get more corporate holdings.
The point is that it is so much easier to view others' behavior accurately than your own. If you peer into your own soul, your findings may revolt you.
We are accusing Israel writ small of the future problem in which we will all be implicated. It's a problem bigger than the US, it's a problem bigger than the West, it's a problem even bigger than capitalism or imperialism. The problem is the luck of being born into a place with the wherewithal to control the entirety of the planet's resources.
Imperialism is every bit the crime people think it is, but it's a deeply misunderstood phenomenon. If you're OK with people dying at pre-industrial revolution mortality rates, then you should be alright with humanity in that perpetually threatened state of nature. Some of us, however, might like better out of life.
It's not like Africa or Latin America knew how to use their natural resources without the West's discoveries, and it's not like imperialism would have never existed without the West. The West only did what every other region was already doing to itself, but by now, its very success at it is what threatens the planet. And therefore, imperialism's greatest crime, the crime that truly sets imperialism alongside Hitler and maybe surpasses him, could be in the future, not the past.
Whatever the total dead in Gaza so far, whatever the total may eventually be, we could be staring down a century of death that makes the 20th century look innocent. In the face of global warming, in the face of misused artificial intelligence, in the face of bioterror and vast nuclear proliferation, this outrage can seem insignificant. And if unprecedented numbers die, it will be people just like the Gazans, billions already relegated to life's margins who could not make it to a safe space. If the misfortune is bad enough, we will all suffer from it, but those of us in affluent countries still have a pretty good shot of surviving. Gaza is just a small tip of a melting iceberg on which billions of people sit, and compared to the crime the entire West and East Asia has perpetrated upon them, Jews as well as goyim, Gaza is just a tiny corner in a vast dry globe of displacement and famine.
Once we stop caring about results more than hypocrisy, we'll com to realize that this crime, something which dwarves even the Shoah, is what we should be working to prevent, Jews, gentiles, Arabs, everybody else, because what's at stake is so much more important than a few university presidents.
This post is too depressing to be this bad. Hopefully I'll say all this better in future weeks.

Tuesday, December 12, 2023

18,000

The first thing to say about that number is there's no way it can be trusted, that's different than saying there's no way it can be true, but we should be extremely skeptical about this number. If nobody comes up with agreed on totals in the Russo-Ukraine war dead within a few hundred thousand, how can we rely on the totals here to the last digit from the health ministry of a totalitarian dictatorship? Even if they've been 'fairly accurate' in the past (as they were rated by Human Rights Watch), this is 'the big one', and Hamas is dependent on optics as never before. Don't misunderstand, I'm sure the real total is well over a few thousand, it may well be quite a bit over 10,000, I would imagine 15,000 is the upper limit, but I suppose it's theoretically possible that the true number is higher than what the Gazan Health Ministry estimated. But even if the Gazan Health Ministry is filled with people of irreproachable integrity, their lives have been threatened by Hamas every day for seventeen years. Long before this war, the lives of Gazan doctors were threatened by Hamas just like anybody else's. If the Health Ministry doesn't release plausibly high death tolls, every person a doctor cares about may become the casualties they refused to make up.

Ask yourselves, if the Gazan Health Ministry is so trustworthy, then how did no one in the Gazan Health Ministry ever warn the world that the central node of Hamas's tunnels with all its weapons was beneath al-Shifa hospital? No one can plausibly claim the medical community didn't know. What would have happened to any doctor or nurse had they warned the world? Would they have died? Would all their co-workers have died? Their families? Would Gaza's largest hospital have been dismantled?

But IF the number is true, even if I doubt it is, then this is a very important number. This is now the most blood Israel has ever spilled in a war. It's generally agreed on that Israel killed a rough total of 17,000 in Lebanon, and that was over a period of 18 years. If Israel appears to kill at this number for an entire year, that total will be somewhere between 100 to 115,000, putting Israel and the Netanyahu administration in a terrible category - even that would not necessarily be a genocide, but it would count as the next worst thing: a democide on the widest possible scale, comparable in scale to 90s Sudan and Somalia even if not in intent - and once it's at that scale, who cares about the difference?

But even if the number is not true, and it probably isn't, the vast world majority will take it on faith that it is, and even if the total number by the time this is over isn't even 18,000 (and no matter what the total, it will eventually be higher than that), the vast majority of the world will insist on proceeding as though this is a Milosevic-level crime. It is, almost certainly, not that, but it's worse, a set stage for much bloodier crimes to come.

Think of here in America: with the news that Jack Smith is moving to the Supreme Court to try to prosecute Trump, this week may be the last realistic chance we get to see if prosecuting Trump can prevent him from becoming President again. If Donald Trump can't in any meaningful sense be prosecuted, then there was no sense in pursuing prosecution to begin with.

How do we know that?

Well, look at Israel. I doubt Netanyahu would have ceded power had he not feared going to jail, but the entire Jewish world disagrees with me. 99% of the Jewish world believes that had Netanyahu not feared prosecution, he would be gone, and we might have had a competent Prime Minister who paid more attention to his intelligence services. If it's true that Netanyahu would have left for a guarantee he wouldn't be prosecuted, then it was never a good idea to prosecute him.

And if that's true for Netanyahu, who clearly likes the job far more than Trump ever did, then it's definitely true for Trump. If we can succeed where Israel has thus far failed with Netanyahu, it will have been worth it, but that is beginning to look so much less than likely.

So look to the future. How will this play out?

There's no way of knowing for sure, but there is an historical precedent right in front of us.

On New Year's Eve 1999, the massively corrupt Boris Yeltsin gave us Vladimir Putin because he needed someone ruthless enough to protect him and his family from jail. Yeltsin, sadly a democrat by Russian standards, still managed to kill somewhere between 30,000-130,000 civillians in Chechnya (let's not get started on the divergence in totals between the two sides...) and displace more than half a million.

Where Putin took his country I don't need to tell you, but look to the Ukraine war for a moment. No one can say just how many are dead, the totals are so incredibly confusing, but what remains clear is that hundreds of thousands are dead and many more yet will die.


The US Republicans may well be about to cut off Ukraine funding because they want accountability for how the bills are paid in a war setting where there is no possible accountability. If Ukraine loses its US funding, Ukraine is almost certain to lose. The biggest bloodbath may be yet to come, and once it's over, Putin will move on: to Belarus? The Baltics? To Moldova? Georgia? How long until Russia is caught red handed in an unforgivable act against a sovereign EU country?

How this could parallel the future of the US is not the purview of this diary, and though it may come up some other day, we're here to talk about Israel.

Netanyahu is not an historic war criminal, modern Israel is not an historic aggressor, not yet at least, but both may just be warmup acts for the real thing. Not now, but in 2035 or 2040. If the Republican party is about to rule the US without a serious challenge for a generation, Israel will have full protection, and being seen already as a state of war criminals, what is the point of holding back? Israel would move against every single threat to its security with its full military might: Gaza and the West Bank, Lebanon, Syria, Iran, wherever an Islamic fundamentalist threat comes from next. The oil plutocrats would be more than happy for Israel to eliminate its biggest religious threats and Israel would just be another authoritarian state grown out of a stale democracy that refused to reform itself until it was too late.

Did six million of us get killed only to...

Monday, December 11, 2023

Israel the Settler-Colonialist State

Fuck you. This isn't hard.
More specifically, the idea proliferates that Israel was a colonialist state from its beginnings. There are small merits to this question, but they're frankly miniscule. Some important Zionist thinkers and leaders proudly called the settling of the Yishuv (pre-Israel Palestine) colonialist among many other things, including socialist, but that was hardly a universal view. Surely the Yishuv had a number of points in common with colonialists, but Jews did not go to Israel to profit off Israel's natural resources - of which Israel has very little, or wage slavery - since nearly the whole point of Zionism was to enable Jews to work the land of their ancestors. Jews went to Israel because there was nowhere else they could freely settle. Imperialism and slavery existed everywhere long before modern white civilizations implemented it, and sometimes on just as large a scale. As I've said many times, Jews suffered from white people 1500-2000 years before 95% of people of color knew what a white person is. In the context of the time, what is remarkable was how little Israel had in common with colonialism.
The reason Israel is considered a colonial state is that the modern far left still sees the world through the aftereffects of modern European imperialism, but European imperialism is basically over except for in Europe itself where Russia is doing its damndest to resurrect its Soviet empire. Israel is one of the very few places where a (quite debatably) white country has anything in common with colonialism, and therefore is the only place where the modern far left can think they've caught white people red-handed in an imperial venture. Never mind that the extreme backbone of the Israeli right is Mizrachi (Middle Eastern) Jews, making up 50% of Israel's population, ejected from Middle Eastern lands in its own Naqba, and incontrovertibly people of color in their very appearance.
The place Israel could be a settler colonialist state is in, obviously, the settlements. This is the only place in Israeli history where the accusation rings true. For obvious reasons. That is the only place, and that is why the settlements must end, and those who live there must and will eventually be forcibly removed in the population transfers that will be an inevitable end to this conflict in which both sides are, by modern technical standards, ethnically cleansed.