Saturday, May 11, 2024
Ten reasons I haven't written about the campus protests so far.
Wednesday, May 8, 2024
One More Thing about Yom HaShoah
There are two Holocaust memorial days. One is International Holocaust Remembrance Day. The other is Yom HaShoah. One is for them, the other is for us.
Yom HaShoah may be an official Israeli holiday, but the speed with which Yom HaShoah took over Jewish memory is unprecedented - it's a holiday that feels as though it had always been there, even to Jews alive before the Shoah or the State of Israel. It is just one of a million ways that you could never separate Jewish identity from Israel. I'd never heard of International Holocaust Remembrance Day before the internet, and I guarantee most Jews hadn't either. For us, Yom HaShoah is the day of Holocaust remembrance, it is the day in Israel, it is the day in the US, it is the day for Jews around the world.
I'll spare you the lecture about Yom HaZikaron and Yom Ha'Atzma'ut.
Tuesday, May 7, 2024
Six Out of Seven: How to talk about the Shoah
Eighty years later, we still don't know how to talk about the Shoah. The key figure is not that six million Jews died, the key figure is that six million died OUT OF SEVEN MILLION. THAT's what makes the Holocaust unique in recorded history. Other numbers are larger, and you'll have to excuse me for mentioning some ghoulish figures, for they all defy belief, but six out of seven is the ratio that makes the suffering of Jews unique among all groups of human beings.
Two Further Thoughts on Rafah: particularly the negotiations
1. There was never going to be a ceasefire agreement, the negotiations were always going to break down. That is Hamas's strategy. The strategic gambit is to bait Israel into offering the maximum number of concessions, then reject them at the last minute as a means of provoking Israel into the maximum possible assault on Rafah and bait Biden into sympathy with Israel's point of view.
Until a significant portion of the world stops making Israel shoulder 100% of the blame and pressures Hamas in the way they pressure Israel, the slaughter will continue.
2. A lot of people are going to say that it's Israel who walked away from the table. That's technically true, but an Egyptian official has already leaked that it was actually Hamas who deliberately blew up the deal. Let's face it, both sides of this table are negotiating in bad faith, and both sides want the Rafah invasion to happen, whether now or in six weeks. The truth, of course, is a much more complicated picture, and you won't get at it unless you're willing to put in the work to see it in the round.
Which everybody is always willing to do when it comes to this conflict...
Monday, May 6, 2024
Facts in the round: Some thoughts at the beginning of Rafah
On the one hand, even if the statistical figures of the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry are true, there is a ratio of civilian to combatant dead that is roughly two combatants for every three civilians, that is unprecedentedly low in modern urban warfare by quite a margin. It means that even the Gaza Health Ministry can't disguise Israelis are generally fighting this war with extreme care.
Wednesday, May 1, 2024
Clarification #2
Nothing about criticizing Israel is antisemitic. It's fantastically naive to go around enraged about all the things Israel does wrong if you're not giving similar criticism to dozens of countries around the world, many of them outright authoritarian regimes, many of which are propped up by the US; not to mention that Jews find the frequency of criticism irritating to the point of enraging, and it steps on all our insecurities that our friends won't look out for us when times get difficult (like now) but no, of course it's not antisemitic to criticize Israel. Israel's a state like any other state, in a complicated situation about which the whole world has lots of feelings, and given the stakes, it's going to fuck up a lot. Criticism is natural.
Rattle's Moments
It's only six months into the Rattle tenure, and the Bavarian Radio Symphony is almost the exact opposite ensemble of what it was five years ago. I'm sure some will view that as a tragedy - and I would number myself one of them except that the Bavarian Radio Symphony of old was a product of its master, and the new one is the product of its master too. If it weren't Mariss Jansons in front of them, the discipline would sound drilled and cold, and if it weren't Simon Rattle now, the lack of discipline would be irritating. Both, however, share a warmth that makes their decisions irrelevant, they are just the outward manifestation of a personality. Jansons was raised in the postwar USSR - born to a Jewish mother in hiding and his musicmaking reflected the drilled nature of his world, Rattle comes from the same Liverpool as Lennon and McCarthy, and his musicmaking reflects the free spirit of his, but in both cases, the warmth of soul is what matters.
Monday, April 29, 2024
One Key Point I Should Have Added Yesterday
There is always a chance that Israel is faking a willingness to invade Rafah as a means of extracting concessions, because if they are, it only works if people truly believe it. But I never put the willingness to do something so reckless past Netanyahu, and I don't put the willingness to sacrifice their people on a scale so massive past Sinwar and Hamas. There has never been a war like this in Israeli history, and there have never been actors on either side willing to sacrifice Palestinians with this much carelessness. This is not just another eruption of brief limited war, this is war in the realest sense: not total war, but the nearest thing to it, and in true war, anything is possible. Whether the threat is meant as a fake or real, it almost doesn't matter, because whether the threat was meant to be real, Israel may be pulled into doing it anyway as a means of keeping their word.
Sunday, April 28, 2024
Again: Just in case my feelings aren't clear
Saturday, April 27, 2024
Goddamnit Evan you promised yourself you wouldn't get geshikkered ever again so here is more about the college protests
Friday, April 26, 2024
Five run-on sentences about the college protests:
I don't ever again want to hear, read, talk, or give two shits about the protestors, for or against. Why does anybody care what happens to a bunch of pro-Palestine and pro-Israel students at places like Columbia who will write their own tickets to an unlimited future when all this is over while the rest of the USA is worried they'll be unable to pay the electric bill in ten years? It's a complete and total distraction from the main story of what's going on over there. Whatever your point of view, it's at least understandable to be outraged about what happens in the main theater of war, but to get outraged about what happens on college campuses is an empty way for powerful people to get you outraged and distracted from the real issues.
Friday, April 19, 2024
So what's going on with Iran and Israel?
Sunday, April 7, 2024
It's Six Months Today
Friday, April 5, 2024
I want it perfectly clear ...
I've said this before, but I want it perfectly clear for anyone who has read all this verbiage I've set down over the last six months.
Well, they've succeeded in fooling the world and then some, but that does not mean Israel has no blame in this, and it does mean that, in some ways, Israel brought it on itself. As usual, there's so much more to say, but the more people say, the less anybody listens.All reactions:
Wednesday, March 27, 2024
Who Is Baltimore?